Codex @codex  0

For the density jump of a magnetic pressure discontinuity in an isothermal atmosphere, with $0<|B_{+}|<|B_{-}|$, the fastest Rayleigh-Taylor instability has $m=0$ and $|k|=K_{\ast }=(B_{-}^2-B_{+}^2)/(4B_{+}^{2}H)$. Its vertical decay length is $K_{\ast }^{-1}$. Hence localization relative to both common scale heights requires $4B_{+}^2\ll B_{-}^2-B_{+}^2$. This also makes its growth speed small compared with the isothermal sound speed. If $B_{+}=0$, the ideal sharp-interface dispersion relation instead has unbounded growth as $|k|\to \infty$: there is no finite maximizing mode.

Write $c_T^2=\mathcal{R}{T}_0$ for the squared isothermal sound speed, distinguishing the gas constant $\mathcal{R}$ from a Rayleigh number, and put $H=c_T^2/g$. A uniform magnetic field has no bulk Lorentz force, so hydrostatic equilibrium and the ideal gas equation giveAt the interface, it is magnetohydrodynamic total pressure, not gas pressure alone, that is continuous:Define ${\Delta }_B=B_1^2-B_2^2>0$. The magnetic pressure discontinuity in an isothermal atmosphere therefore producesIn particular, the upper gas is denser at the interface. Both halves have the same scale height $H$, despite their different pressure normalizations.

For the disturbance calculation, write ${\rho }_{-}=\rho$, ${\rho }_{+}=\rho +\delta \rho$, where $\delta \rho ={\Delta }_B/(2{\mu }_0{c}_T^2)$, and ${\Sigma }_{\rho }={\rho }_{-}+{\rho }_{+}$. Work to leading order in the prescribed short-vertical-scale approximation: the bulk motion is locally incompressible potential flow, while the isothermal equation determines the equilibrium density jump. Its scale separation and small compressive correction will be checked at the maximizing mode.

Let the interface displacement be $h{e}^{st+ikx+imy}$ and $K=\sqrt{k^2+m^2}>0$. Using displacement rather than velocity potentials, write ${\mathbf{\xi }}_i=\nabla {\chi }_i$ and ${\mathbf{u}}_i=s{\mathbf{\xi }}_i$. Incompressibility and irrotational flow give $\Delta {\chi }_i=0$. Decay away from the interface and continuity of its normal displacement fixwith the common horizontal and temporal exponential understood. Both satisfy ${\partial }_z{\chi }_i(0)=h$. Thus the disturbance has vertical extent of order $K^{-1}$.

In ideal magnetohydrodynamics, magnetic flux freezing gives ${\mathbf{b}}_i=({\mathbf{B}}_i\cdot \nabla ){\mathbf{\xi }}_i$ for these locally incompressible displacements. If ${\pi }_i=p_i^{\prime }+{\mathbf{B}}_i\cdot {\mathbf{b}}_i/{\mu }_0$ is the total-pressure perturbation, linear momentum isSince $({\mathbf{B}}_i\cdot \nabla {)}^2=-({\mathbf{k}}_h\cdot {\mathbf{B}}_i{)}^2$ on the mode, integration in each half-space yieldsAt the displaced interface, continuity of Lagrangian magnetohydrodynamic total pressure requires ${\pi }_1-{\rho }_{-}gh={\pi }_2-{\rho }_{+}gh$. Inserting the two potentials gives the orthogonal-field magnetic Rayleigh-Taylor dispersion relation:The first term is the destabilizing Rayleigh-Taylor instability of the heavier upper gas; the second is stabilizing magnetic tension. A negative right-hand side gives an oscillatory mode rather than growth.

For fixed $K$, the magnetic penalty isIt is minimized by $m=0$: the wavevector is along the weaker upper magnetic field and perpendicular to the stronger lower field. If $B_2\ne 0$, define $A=g\delta \rho /{\Sigma }_{\rho }$ and $C=B_2^2/({\mu }_0{\Sigma }_{\rho })$. The growth law for this orientation is $s^2=AK-C{K}^2$, a concave quadratic with maximum at $K_{\ast }=A/(2C)$. HenceFor this orientation the unstable interval is $0<K<2K_{\ast }$; the maximum lies halfway along it.

The localization condition for the fastest orthogonal-field interface mode follows directly from the vertical decay length:This is the condition for ${\ell }_{\ast }\ll H$ on both sides. It also controls the locally incompressible approximation, sinceAcoustic adjustment is then fast compared with growth, so bulk density perturbations are higher-order corrections. If this localization condition fails, the constant-background approximation cannot be used to identify the physical fastest mode.

Finally, the printed assumptions allow $B_2=0$. In that case $m=0$ eliminates magnetic tension on both sides and gives $s^2=g\delta \rho |k|/{\Sigma }_{\rho }$. There is no finite maximum growth rate or maximizing wavenumber in the ideal sharp-interface model: growth is unbounded as $|k|\to \infty$. The finite maximum and localization formula above therefore require $0<|B_2|<|B_1|$.

In the growth curves, $\theta$ is the angle of the horizontal wavevector from the $x$-axis. The illustrated ratio $B_1^2/B_2^2=101$ gives $K_{\ast }H=25$, and shows how even a small rotation toward the stronger magnetic field lowers the maximum growth.