Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2012 iii Paper 3 5 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
The coordinate ring is . The induced action is contragredient on functions:It is a group action by degree-preserving algebra automorphisms, extending the dual action on linear polynomial functions. Its polynomial invariant ring isFor a monic polynomial , its polynomial discriminant is . This is symmetric in the roots, hence polynomial in the coefficients, and is zero exactly when a root is repeated.
For the alternating group action, let be the elementary symmetric polynomials and put . If is -invariant and is any transposition, decomposeNormality and index two of show that is symmetric and transforms by the sign character of . Any alternating polynomial vanishes when , so every divides it. These pairwise nonassociate prime factors have product , so with symmetric. The Fundamental theorem of symmetric polynomials yieldsThe sum is direct, since a polynomial that is both symmetric and alternating is zero in characteristic zero. Also , where is the discriminant polynomial ofThus, more precisely than the requested quotient assertion,Surjectivity follows from the direct-sum expression. Divide any putative kernel element by the monic quadratic in ; its remainder is . The direct sum forces , and algebraic independence of the gives . Hence the displayed relation is the entire kernel. The argument also covers , where is trivial.
Now let be finite with no nontrivial linear characters, and write , . The polynomial ring is a unique factorization domain. Factor a nonzero invariant in ; invariance permutes the associate classes of its irreducible factors and makes their exponents constant on each orbit. For an orbit , choose representatives and form its orbit product of polynomial factorsFor every , for a nonzero scalar . Applying two group elements proves that is a homomorphism. The hypothesis forces , so .
This orbit product is prime in . If it divides with , one factor divides or in . Invariance of that chosen polynomial makes every factor in the orbit divide it. Their product therefore divides it in , and the quotient is invariant because numerator and denominator are invariant and cancellation is valid in the integral domain . Thus divides or in . Every nonzero is a scalar times a product of these prime orbit products, and the only units of are nonzero constants, as they are units in . Therefore is a unique factorization domain. This gives a direct proof, without assuming a divisor-class-group theorem.
For a failure in characteristic zero, let the cyclic group of order two act on by . Its coordinate invariants areEvery invariant monomial has even total degree: its exponents are either both even, or both odd, giving the indicated generators. Reducing powers of to at most one shows that is the only relation, since and map to distinct monomials. The three quadratic invariants are irreducible in : each nonconstant invariant has degree at least two, so a product of two nonunits has degree at least four. They are pairwise nonassociate, butgives two different irreducible factorizations. Hence this invariant ring is not a unique factorization domain. The nontrivial sign character is precisely the kind of character excluded in the preceding theorem.