Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2003 / iii / Paper 67 / 2 / b / Solution

Only $\alpha >0$ needs consideration, by the preceding zero-stability analysis. On the Dahlquist test equation, all roots of the amplification polynomialmust satisfy the unit-disk root condition if the method is A-stable. Evaluate it at $\zeta =-1$:Take a real negative $z<-4/\alpha$. Then $P_z(-1)<0$, whereas the leading coefficient $2+\alpha -z$ is positive and $P_z(\zeta )\to +\infty$ as $\zeta \to -\infty$. The intermediate value theorem gives a real root strictly below $-1$. Its numerical mode grows in modulus, contradicting absolute stability at this negative test parameter. ConsequentlyThis proof detects an unstable root directly; the second-order value alone would not exclude A-stability. Equivalently the limiting derivative polynomial has an exterior root $-\alpha -\sqrt{1+{\alpha }^2}$, explaining the instability for large negative $z$.