Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2009 / iii / Paper 5 / 3 / v

Set $P_0=G$ and $P_{i+1}=P_i^p$. The permitted power-embedding result, applied repeatedly, gives $[P_i,G]\le P_{i+1}$, and each $P_i$ is a powerful p-group. These subgroups eventually reach $1$: if $P_i\ne 1$, its Frattini subgroup $P_i^p$ is proper. In fact these are the lower p-series layers, with their indices shifted by one.

For $x\in G$ and $y\in P_i$, the commutator $[y,x]$ lies in $P_{i+1}$, is central modulo $P_{i+2}$, and has exponent dividing $p$ there. The class-two collection calculation from part (iv) therefore givesApplying part (iv) inside $P_i$, whose third lower-series term is contained in $P_{i+2}$, shows that the map $y\mapsto y^p$ is onto $P_{i+1}/P_{i+2}$.

Given $a\in P_1$, first choose $x$ with $x^p\equiv a(\mathrm{mod}{P}_2)$. Suppose $x^p\equiv a(\mathrm{mod}{P}_{i+1})$. Choose $y\in P_i$ with $y^p\equiv x^{-p}a(\mathrm{mod}{P}_{i+2})$. The displayed collection congruence then gives $(xy{)}^p\equiv a(\mathrm{mod}{P}_{i+2})$. Replacing $x$ by $xy$ improves the approximation by one layer. Since the filtration on a group terminates, a finite sequence of corrections gives $x^p=a$ exactly. The reverse inclusion is the definition of $G^p$. Hence