Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2022 / iii / Paper 112 / 2 / a / Solution

Apply the Kauffman bracket skein relation to every crossing in the two-string tangle $D_1$. Each complete smoothing is a collection of closed circles together with one of the two crossingless pairings of the four boundary points. Rotation through $180^{\circ }$ about the indicated vertical axis preserves both crossingless pairings and the number of closed circles. Gluing the unchanged tangle $D_2$ to corresponding smoothings therefore gives equal terms, including equal loop factors, so $⟨D⟩=⟨D^{\prime }⟩$.

Choose an orientation of $L$, and transport the induced orientations of the four ends of $D_1$ through the rotation to orient $L^{\prime }$. Crossing signs inside the rotated tangle and outside it then have the same total, so the writhe of a link diagram satisfies $w(D)=w(D^{\prime })$. Applying the writhe normalization of the Jones polynomial gives