Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2022 / iii / Paper 341 / Section A / 4

A real linear operator $\mathcal{L}$ on an inner-product space is a positive-definite operator when it is self-adjoint andfor every nonzero $u$ in its domain. In the variational setting one normally requires the stronger uniform estimate $⟨\mathcal{L}u,u⟩\ge c\Vert u{\Vert }_V^2$ for some $c>0$, which is coercivity.

Choose the Sobolev space $V$ encoding the homogeneous essential boundary conditions, setafter the appropriate integration by parts, and define the energy functionalIts first variation is $J^{\prime }(u)v=a(u,v)-\ell (v)$, so its stationary points are exactly the solutions of the weak formulationIf $a$ is bounded, symmetric, and coercive and $\ell \in V^{\prime }$, the Lax-Milgram theorem supplies a unique weak solution $u$. Moreover, for every $w\in V$,unless $w=0$. Thus $J$ is strictly convex, and $u$ is its unique global minimizer. This proves existence and uniqueness of the minimizer and of the weak solution simultaneously.

Let $\Omega =(-1,1{)}^2$ and use the clamped energy space $V=H_0^2(\Omega )$, whose traces satisfy $u={\partial }_{n}u=0$ on $\partial \Omega$. Two applications of integration by parts giveIf equality holds, then $\Delta u=0$. The maximum principle for harmonic functions and the zero Dirichlet boundary condition imply $u=0$. The biharmonic operator is therefore positive definite. The same identity and conclusion hold for the simply supported conditions $u=\Delta u=0$; either standard interpretation of the paper's phrase “zero boundary conditions” gives the result.