= Solution
Use an <independent> copy $(x',y')$ of $(x,y)$ under the <product measure> $\Pi\otimes\Pi$. Write $q=y-x$, $q'=y'-x'$, and
$$
r_t=z_t-z'_t=(1-t)(x-x')+t(y-y'),\qquad a=q-q'.
$$
Since the <pushforward measure> of $\Pi\otimes\Pi$ under $(z_t,z'_t)$ is $\mu_t\otimes\mu_t$, the <interaction energy> is
$$
\mathcal W[\mu_t]=\frac12\iint W(r_t)\,d\Pi(x,y)\,d\Pi(x',y').
$$
Two applications of the <chain rule> give
$$
\boxed{\frac{d^2}{dt^2}\mathcal W[\mu_t]=\frac12\iint (q-q')^TD^2W(z_t-z'_t)(q-q')\,d\Pi\,d\Pi'.}
$$
The factor $1/2$ is retained. This classical identity requires <differentiation under the integral sign> to be justified, just as in part (b). Bounded <Hessian matrix> of $W$ is sufficient, since $|q-q'|^2\leq2|q|^2+2|q'|^2$ is integrable; compactly supported endpoints are another sufficient case. The printed quadratic-growth condition alone does not provide this domination.
The failure can occur for the <interaction energy> too. Take the even <interaction potential> $W(x)=1-\cos(2\pi x^3)$ and replace the endpoint <probability measures> in part (b) by $\frac12\delta_0+\frac12\mu$ and $\frac12\delta_0+\frac12\nu$. Keep the origin fixed and translate every other atom by one. This coupling is increasing on the line, hence is optimal: its assigned values extend to a nondecreasing <transport map>, which is the <gradient> of a <convex function>. Differences between translated atoms remain integers, so their mutual interaction vanishes. Only interactions with the origin contribute, giving $\mathcal W[\mu_t]=F(t)/4$, with $F$ from part (b). It therefore also lacks a finite classical <second derivative> at $t=1/2$.
Back to article page
