Jeffreys-Lindley paradox for a Gaussian point null Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-11-05
Suppose independently, and compare with for fixed , using equal prior model probabilities. Put . The posterior probability of a Gaussian point null is
Holding fixed while leaves the two-sided p-value unchanged but makes the null posterior probability tend to one. For , and , the p-value is about , while the null posterior is about .
The two procedures answer different model-based questions: a tail probability under the point null and a comparison of that null with a specified alternative prior distribution. The alternative's fixed prior scale spreads mass over parameter values much wider than the increasingly precise likelihood. This is the Jeffreys-Lindley phenomenon, not a conversion formula from p-values to posterior probabilities.[ref]
Bayes' formula divides the point-null contribution to the mixture density by the full marginal density:
Since
the posterior probability of a Gaussian point null is