For three distinct players in a normalized simple cooperative game, enumerate the predecessor coalitions in the Shapley value formula:Subtracting the formula with and exchanged proves the displayed identity. Every coalition value is zero or one, so is an integer. This rules out, for example, coordinates differing by , although each may separately satisfy the Shapley value denominator in a simple game. The difference identity itself holds for arbitrary three-player transferable utility games; the integer restriction uses the zero-one values.
No. In a simple cooperative game, a player's marginal contribution along any permutation is zero or one. With three players there are six equally likely permutations, so every Shapley value is an integer multiple of , by the Shapley value denominator in a simple game. But and are not integers. The vector sums to one, but fails this necessary denominator condition.