Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2009 iii Paper 57 3 iii Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
For photon-dominated inertia, and . The baryon expansion and pressure terms are suppressed by . Ignoring metric driving as stipulated, the common-velocity Euler equation is . Differentiating the photon continuity equation givesThis limit is compatible with a matter-dominated background: cold dark matter can dominate the expansion while photons dominate the inertia of the photon-baryon subsystem.
In the first nonzero quadrupole approximation, neglect relative to its collision damping. The shear equation givesSubstitution yields the shear-only photon diffusion damping equationThe sign of the first-derivative term is positive, so finite photon mean free time damps acoustic energy.
Put and . For constant , the characteristic roots are . The frequency shift begins at second order in the mean free time. To the requested order the general solution iswhere the error describes the frequency expansion at fixed and time interval. Keeping the exponential retains the accumulated damping rather than expanding away a possibly important effect.
For a general time-dependent coefficient, a first-order solution with prescribed initial conditions can also be written aswhere . Substitution verifies that the integral solves the oscillator forced by , and its value and first derivative vanish initially. This gives the general first-order result without assuming arbitrary time dependence may be absorbed exactly into an exponential.
To obtain the slowly varying subhorizon form, set with . The exact transformed equation isDropping the quadratic term alone leaves , so slow variation is also needed. When , , and the mean free time changes on an expansion timescale, . The WKB method solution has local frequency and prefactor . At leading acoustic order both reduce to constants; the small derivative corrections to phase and prefactor can be neglected. This slowly varying shear-damped photon oscillator therefore givesA change in the phase origin is absorbed into . At zero mean free time the damping vanishes; as time passes the diffusion length grows and decreases. The coefficient is that of the question's isotropic-scattering, shear-only truncation, not the polarization-inclusive full Silk damping formula.
If ionization remains approximately constant during matter domination, , so . Away from the lower limit this givesNear recombination the rapidly changing ionization fraction and eventual failure of tight coupling require the full hierarchy; the integral formula specifies the damping accumulated during the regime used here.