For the spherical null expansions in double-null coordinates, the cross-sectional area of a symmetry sphere is . For the two affine null geodesic congruences, the definition of null expansion therefore gives
There is no extra derivative of in these formulas: the null expansion differentiates the transverse area, not the normalization of the tangent. Equivalently, the projected metric is and its optical tensor is , or for the other congruence. It is purely trace, so both null shears vanish.
The null twist vanishes because the covector tangents are gradients of and , and hence their exterior derivatives vanish. Each congruence is orthogonal to a family of null hypersurfaces. This also identifies the Frobenius theorem reason for zero null twist.
Persistence of spherical trapping Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-11-05
Consider a regular four-dimensional region with spherical symmetry and two null coordinates,
with both and future directed. Assume the Einstein field equations and null energy condition, so .
Suppose on an initial Cauchy hypersurface. In the portion of its future domain of dependence whose past constant- null segments reach that hypersurface within the regular coordinate region, let their initial coordinate be . The double-null focusing identity integrates to
Thus the ingoing spherical null expansion remains negative there.
Now take a sphere with the other expansion negative as well. Along its future outgoing null hypersurface ,
Both spherical null expansions in double-null coordinates are therefore negative on every surviving sphere of that outgoing null hypersurface, so those spheres remain trapped surfaces. The result applies while the stated regularity and domain conditions hold.
Each focusing identity controls variation along its own null direction. A claim about every sphere in a whole two-dimensional future region needs an additional argument controlling the transverse direction; the two separate inequalities above establish the stated generator-by-generator persistence.