Differentiate the Friedmann equation and use cosmological energy conservation:
For an expanding universe , division by and substitution of the Friedmann equation give the Friedmann acceleration equation
The strong energy condition makes . Since and ,
Thus the quantity is nonincreasing, with strict decrease when the energy condition is strict. Dividing the Friedmann equation by yields
For fixed nonzero curvature, the magnitude of grows as expansion decelerates. The observed closeness to one therefore requires much tighter early-time closeness to one in the standard decelerating model: this is the flatness problem. Accelerated expansion during inflation reverses this evolution and suppresses the curvature contribution.
Differentiation of the Hubble parameter gives . The strong energy condition and the acceleration equation therefore imply
Assume the present universe is expanding, , and normalize the scale factor by . Since , the past expanding branch has . On this branch,
Integrating from a past time to gives . Thus, where the denominator is positive,
The printed inequality needs this past-time qualification: for future times with , the inequality reverses. Independently, a concave function lies below its tangent, so
Positivity of prevents the past branch extending before the zero of this tangent. If is the beginning of the expanding universe, its age satisfies . Without the normalization , the tangent bound instead reads .
The Hubble parameter is the fractional expansion rate
Here is the homogeneous energy density, records the sign of the spatial curvature of an FLRW universe, and is the fixed curvature length scale used with the dimensionless scale factor .
Energy-momentum conservation in a homogeneous expanding universe gives the continuity equation
Differentiate the Friedmann equation
Using and the continuity equation gives
Eliminating the curvature term with the Friedmann equation yields
Since , this is the Raychaudhuri equation
Under the strong energy condition , one has . Thus is concave, and for it lies below its tangent at the present time:
The right side vanishes at . A positive scale factor therefore cannot extend regularly to that time; it must reach the Big Bang singularity at some . Equivalently,
The strong energy condition and Einstein's equation imply . Since the congruence is hypersurface orthogonal, its vorticity vanishes. The tensor in the hint is the trace-free spatial shear, so
Because , part b gives