False with the printed in the paper. Let the even-indexed surfaces be one fixed unit sphere and the odd-indexed surfaces one fixed ring torus. Then
but infinitely many surfaces are tori. The two fixed surfaces lie in one ball and have uniformly bounded area. Their injectivity radii have a positive common lower bound, and compactness gives a common bound on , hence on every radial derivative . Thus this alternating sequence satisfies all four additional conditions as well.
The intended statement becomes true if is replaced by
Here is the proof. Put , so . Choose maximizing distance from the centre of the fixed containing ball. The supporting-sphere curvature bound gives
Write and in geodesic polar coordinates. Choose a fixed sufficiently small and set . Conditions (3) and (4) allow to be chosen so that and
The Jacobi equation , with and , and the Sturm comparison theorem then give on this ball for a constant independent of . Consequently
Since elsewhere and ,
for all sufficiently large . Gauss-Bonnet forces , and the classification theorem for surfaces makes each such a sphere.
Take
Its consecutive zeros are and . For the stated equation,
and is not identically equal to on the interval. The Sturm comparison theorem therefore shows that every nontrivial solution has at least one zero in
Suppose has no zero in . It has a constant sign there, so replace it by its negative if needed and apply part (i). The conclusion is on that interval. Taking the contrapositive proves the Sturm comparison theorem: unless the coefficients agree identically, has a zero between the consecutive zeros of .
Rewrite the equation as
On , one has . If a nontrivial solution had two zeros, choose two consecutive ones in that interval. Then .
The solution
of is strictly positive on . Since and the coefficients are not identical on this interval, the Sturm comparison theorem requires to have a zero between and , a contradiction. Hence every nontrivial solution has