The derivative hypothesis implies that is a symbol of order at high frequency. Choose cutoffs in and a high-frequency cutoff in . The corresponding Fourier multiplier is a parametrix for , and the symbol calculus, together with the product formula from part (b), gives the localized estimate
for some sufficiently negative . The commutator terms contain derivatives ; the assumed factor lowers their order and lets them be absorbed inductively. Therefore
If is smooth, it belongs locally to for every . Starting from the fact that every compactly supported distribution has some negative Sobolev order and repeatedly applying the gain places in every local Sobolev space. The Sobolev embedding theorem then gives . Thus is a hypoelliptic differential operator.
The assumed lower bound gives at large frequency. Differentiating repeatedly expresses every derivative as a finite sum of products of derivatives of divided by powers of . Since has polynomial order at most , induction and symbol calculus give
The interpolation region is compact in frequency and causes no problem. Hence
The symbol class consists of such that, for every compact and all multi-indices ,
The defining estimate gives
The Leibniz rule gives
and the triangle inequality gives
These are the basic rules of symbol calculus.
Take
By symbol calculus, . Its zeroth-order contribution is outside the compact transition region and therefore cancels the order remainder. Every term in
contains at least one derivative of and has order at most . Absorbing these terms and the smoothing cutoff contribution into gives