Amenability of a free product 2026-10-03
For nontrivial groups , the free product is amenable exactly in the exceptional case . In that case it is the infinite dihedral group, hence a virtually cyclic group and amenable. In every other case the normal form theorem for a free product and the ping-pong lemma produce a subgroup isomorphic to ; the fact that a subgroup of an amenable group is amenable then obstructs amenability.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2023 iii Paper 133 2 c Solution 2026-09-28
Let be a finite-index subgroup of , let , and project onto its factor. Then has finite index in , while the image of is for some . Choose projecting to . Every element of has a unique expression with , and conjugation by on is the restriction of . ThusBecause is not an eigenvalue of , part (b), applied to the finite-rank lattice , shows that the image of in is finite. The quotient by that finite image is generated by the image of , so is a finite extension of an infinite cyclic group. It is therefore a virtually cyclic group.