Limit cardinal Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-31
An infinite cardinal number is a limit cardinal if it is not a successor cardinal; equivalently it is an aleph number with zero or a limit ordinal as index. Uncountable limit cardinals are either singular cardinals or weakly inaccessible cardinals. This concerns succession among cardinals, rather than merely being a limit ordinal.
Consistency of ZFC implies consistency of ZFC with the Generalized continuum hypothesis and no weakly inaccessible cardinals. Pass to the constructible universe. If it has an inaccessible, cut at its least one; that rank segment still models ZFC and the Generalized continuum hypothesis, but has no inaccessibles. In this model the singular cardinal enumeration is continuous at every nonzero limit ordinal index. This is a relative-consistency construction, not a deduction of a transitive model from bare consistency.
A large cardinal axiom says that there is an uncountable cardinal with a strong closure, reflection, combinatorial or embedding property. Its interest is not merely the magnitude of the cardinal: it packages a universe-like portion of set theory, or a coherent way of comparing the universe with a proper inner model. Such axioms form a hierarchy extending ordinary ZFC, compared through relative consistency implications. The consistency qualifications are essential; an existence axiom is not a theorem of ZFC simply because its consequences are attractive.
The basic example is a strongly inaccessible cardinal: an uncountable regular cardinal which is a strong limit cardinal, so
These conditions imply for every . Prove this by induction along the cumulative hierarchy: the successor step uses the strong-limit property, and a limit step uses regularity to bound a union of fewer than smaller sets. Thus every member of has cardinality below .
Consequently is a transitive model of ZFC. Pairing, union, power set, separation, axiom of infinity and foundation stay within the hierarchy. For replacement, a definable function on has fewer than values; regularity bounds their ranks below , putting the range in . Ambient choice supplies a choice function for a family in , and its graph also has bounded rank. This verifies the substantial closure axiom rather than only saying that the rank is large. It also shows why inaccessible existence cannot be proved in a consistent ZFC: it would yield a set first-order model of ZFC and hence its consistency, contrary to the Gödel second incompleteness theorem.
An uncountable regular limit cardinal is a weakly inaccessible cardinal; requiring the strong-limit inequality is stronger without additional hypotheses. Under GCH, every smaller infinite cardinal satisfies , so the two notions coincide. This distinction separates cardinal-arithmetic assumptions from the regularity requirement.
A Mahlo cardinal is an inaccessible whose inaccessible cardinals below it form a stationary set. Thus every club set meets those inaccessibles, which strengthens mere unboundedness. There are inaccessible ; is a first-order model of ZFC containing an inaccessible . Mahloness therefore supplies a consistency statement stronger than the bare existence of one inaccessible. Iterating the demand that smaller cardinals have the same reflection property leads to further levels of the hierarchy.
A weakly compact cardinal is a logical and combinatorial strengthening of inaccessibility. One standard characterization is an inaccessible with
every two-colouring of pairs has a homogeneous subset of size . Equivalently one can use compactness for theories of size at most , or the tree property at an inaccessible. These viewpoints explain the terminology: a local collection of compatible requirements has a global realization, and tall narrow trees cannot avoid cofinal branches. They are characterization statements; the elementary closure and measure arguments below are separate proofs of the consequences used here.
A measurable cardinal carries a nonprincipal kappa-complete ultrafilter on . Every set of size less than is -null, since it is a union of fewer than null singletons. Such a cardinal is regular: a cofinal sequence of length would partition into bounded, hence null, pieces; completeness would make their union null, an impossibility.
It is also strong limit. If and there were distinct sets for , choose for each the -large side of the partition according to whether . The intersection of these fewer than large sides belongs to , but all its indices designate the same subset of , so it has at most one member. This contradicts nonprincipality. Hence , proving that every measurable cardinal is inaccessible.
The measure gives an ultrapower embedding. Form equivalence classes of functions under equality on a -large set, with membership defined coordinatewise modulo . Induction on first-order formulas proves elementarity: Boolean operations use the ultrafilter laws, and the existential step chooses coordinate witnesses on a large set. Countable completeness makes the ultrapower well-founded. An infinite descending membership chain would give countably many large coordinate conditions; their intersection would produce an actual infinite membership descent in . Collapse the ultrapower to a transitive class , obtaining .
For , every function into is constant on a large set by completeness; induction shows . The class of the identity function is larger than every such constant ordinal and lies below , so . Thus the critical point of an elementary embedding is . The measure viewpoint has become a precise self-similarity principle for the universe.
A supercompact cardinal imposes arbitrarily strong closure on these embeddings: for every there is with critical point , , and . It implies measurability by the derived ultrafilter
Elementarity makes this an ultrafilter; fixed ordinals below show that singletons are null. For , fixes the indexing length, so it carries an intersection of sets to the intersection of their images. If all these images contain , so does their intersection, proving -completeness.
These examples illustrate three connected uses of large cardinals: obtaining set first-order models and stronger consistency statements, extending finite or countable compactness and partition phenomena to uncountable domains, and constructing elementary embeddings with controlled closure. They also interact with inner models: an inaccessible remains inaccessible in the constructible universe, since it cannot acquire a new short cofinal sequence there and there are fewer subsets of smaller ordinals. A measurable cardinal's measure need not belong to that inner model, so preservation of the stronger property is a different issue. Large cardinal axioms are thus structured additional hypotheses, with carefully distinguishable consequences and relative-consistency claims, rather than a single claim that sufficiently big cardinals exist.
A strongly inaccessible cardinal is an uncountable cardinal that is both regular and a strong limit:
Regularity excludes expressing as the supremum of a shorter increasing sequence, while the strong-limit requirement concerns all smaller power sets. Merely being an uncountable regular limit cardinal is the weaker notion of a weakly inaccessible cardinal.
Yes. A cardinal fixed point of the singular cardinal enumeration is obtained by countable iteration. Start with and put
The singular cardinal enumeration is strictly increasing and satisfies for every ordinal ; the latter follows by transfinite induction for any strictly increasing ordinal-valued enumeration. If equality occurs at some , that cardinal number is already a witness. Otherwise the sequence is strictly increasing. Put . This is an uncountable singular cardinal of cofinality .
For every , some has , and therefore
Also , so . At a limit ordinal index, if the supremum of all preceding enumerated cardinals is itself singular, it is exactly the next member: every smaller singular cardinal already has a preceding index. Thus
This argument uses continuity only at a singular supremum; the enumeration need not be continuous at a weakly inaccessible cardinal.
It suffices to obtain a model of ZFC without weakly inaccessible cardinals. Starting with any model of ZFC, pass to its constructible universe, which satisfies ZFC and the Generalized continuum hypothesis. If it has no inaccessible cardinal, use that model. Otherwise pass to its rank segment at its least inaccessible cardinal . This segment satisfies ZFC, retains the Generalized continuum hypothesis, and has no inaccessible cardinals. Under the Generalized continuum hypothesis, every weakly inaccessible cardinal is strongly inaccessible: if and is a limit cardinal, then . Thus in either case the resulting model has no weakly inaccessible cardinals.
Work inside . If is a nonzero limit ordinal, let . It is an uncountable limit cardinal. If it were regular, it would be a weakly inaccessible cardinal, which is impossible in . It is therefore singular, and the singular cardinal enumeration is continuous at this index:
The cofinality of an increasing ordinal supremum now gives
for every nonzero limit ordinal in . Hence satisfies the negation of the proposed existential assertion. By the soundness theorem for first-order logic, consistency of ZFC prevents ZFC from proving that assertion. The model construction is a relative-consistency argument; it does not assume that consistency alone supplies a countable transitive model. Here, as usual, a limit ordinal excludes zero.
Weakly inaccessible cardinals are unbounded below the given cardinal. In fact, they form a stationary set there. Let be the weakly Mahlo cardinal, so it is a regular uncountable limit cardinal and the set is stationary.
The set of uncountable limit cardinals below is a club set. For unboundedness, above any starting point choose a strictly increasing countable sequence of cardinal numbers below ; its supremum remains below by regularity and is an uncountable limit cardinal. For closure, a limit of such limit cardinals is again a limit cardinal.
Every is an uncountable regular cardinal and a limit cardinal, hence a weakly inaccessible cardinal. The intersection of a stationary set with a club set is stationary, because its intersection with any further club is nonempty. Therefore
This proves the stronger form of the requested conclusion.
Singular cardinal enumeration Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-07
Write for the th uncountable singular cardinal in increasing order. It begins with and . At a nonzero limit ordinal index it is continuous exactly when the supremum of its earlier values is singular. It can jump when that supremum is a weakly inaccessible cardinal. The first member of uncountable cofinality occurs at index , with value .
Weakly Mahlo cardinal 2026-10-06
A weakly inaccessible cardinal is weakly Mahlo if is a stationary set. Intersecting this set with the club set of uncountable limit cardinals shows that the weakly inaccessible cardinals below are stationary, hence unbounded.