Ciro Santilli @cirosantilli 34

OK, the Good film tag might imply that you are a Sinophile.

The adaptation is very loose.

Many bad films have good aspects. They just didn't cross the elusive threshold of a good film.

Way, way, way too much running and fighting.

Also way too idealistic :Sliding Scale of Idealism vs. Cynicism.

Also the good/evil is way too black and white.

If only everything was instead funny and charming and intelligent like the very first part in the Shire... that section and others interspersed withing the running are good film level.