Since is lifted from , its covariant derivative is also lifted from . Part (ii) therefore gives . It also gives , and part (i) gives . Substituting into the Riemannian curvature two-form definition yields
With the four-slot convention fixed above, this proves
For nonzero lifted vectors from different factors they are orthogonal, so the sectional-curvature denominator is positive. Hence the corresponding mixed plane has sectional curvature zero, providing the mixed-plane value in the example.
The product Riemannian metric has block matrix
In the given Christoffel symbols formula, every mixed coefficient vanishes. Off-diagonal metric entries are zero, , and . These facts give for every output index , as well as and . The remaining pure blocks are precisely the Christoffel symbols of the respective factor metrics.
For the lifted fields of (i), . Consequently
Thus . The same calculation gives ; differentiating two fields from one factor gives the lifted factor covariant derivative. This identifies the product Levi-Civita connection with the product affine connection and proves the curvature splitting used in the root solution.
Use product coordinates on and on . The lifted vector fields have the form and . The coefficients of each depend only on its own coordinate set, and the coordinate partial derivatives commute. The Lie bracket of vector fields formula therefore gives
Thus for fields lifted separately from the two factors. The lift hypothesis matters: arbitrary product-manifold fields can have coefficients depending on both factors.
For , the surface presentation
has an epimorphism to sending to and the other generators to zero. Its kernel has index . By the classification of connected covering spaces, it determines a connected -sheeted cover . Pull back the orientation, so each local sheet has degree and . Counting lifts of cells gives , hence and .
For , use the -sheeted cover and compose with an orientation-reversing diffeomorphism of , for instance reflection in a symmetric embedded genus-two surface. By multiplicativity of mapping degree, the degree becomes . For take a constant map from the torus. Thus the arbitrary-degree maps to a surface of genus two can be chosen with
Choose an oriented embedded closed -disc in and collapse to a point. The quotient is , with orientation chosen to agree on the disc interior. The resulting collapse map of degree one onto a sphere is
Indeed, any target point other than the collapsed point has exactly one preimage, where the map is an orientation-preserving homeomorphism and has local degree . The degree as a sum of local degrees therefore gives global degree one. This is the usual connected, positive-dimensional setting for mapping degree; extra components, if allowed, may all be collapsed.
Identify with the product of two unit circles and use the unit sphere . The surjective degree-zero sphere-to-torus map is
Given any torus point, choose its two angle representatives with . Then , so completes a preimage on the sphere. Thus the map is surjective. The explicit homotopy , , contracts it to a constant map. By homotopy invariance of mapping degree, , despite surjectivity.
Using complex coordinates near zero, for induces winding number on a small circle, so its local relative homology multiplier is . For , has local degree , since conjugation reverses the winding. For zero, take : its zero fiber is the single point zero, while the image of a small circle is a single positive real point, so its local degree is zero. Equivalently a nearby nonreal target has no preimages.
Each of these maps is proper and hence extends continuously over the one-point compactifications to a map with zero as an isolated preimage of zero. Thus
These are local degrees of arbitrary integer value. Taking times the identity on gives the same local degrees for every . In dimension one, an isolated local degree is restricted to , so the all-integers assertion is realized in dimensions at least two.
Use the following permitted kernel result, stated in the form needed here. For an Anosov flow generated by a smooth surface thermostat on a closed oriented Riemannian surface, if a smooth function on satisfies
where is a smooth base function and is a smooth one-form, then and is an exact differential form. Conversely these two conditions give a smooth solution by taking a base primitive. This is the kernel of the thermostat X-ray transform in degrees zero and one. In particular it applies to Gaussian thermostats without an additional curvature condition; it is stronger than the magnetic or geodesic special case.
Put , so . Suppose the thermostat preserves a smooth volume form. Write it as with smooth , choosing its sign separately on each component if necessary. By the invariant volume criterion for a smooth flow and the divergence computation in part (b),
Thus is a smooth solution of . Apply the stated kernel theorem with to obtain for a smooth base function . The definition of the gradient then gives .
Conversely, suppose . Since , the vertical part has no effect on a base function and
The divergence of a Gaussian thermostat and the volume-change formula therefore give
Consequently
Only the necessary direction uses the Anosov kernel theorem; the displayed invariant density works for any potential Gaussian thermostat. In particular its exponent is positive, as required to cancel the negative divergence found in part (b).
This is a Gaussian thermostat, with generator and angular acceleration
The canonical fields and preserve Liouville volume of a surface geodesic flow. To check this directly, use the canonical coframe of a surface unit tangent bundle , with dual frame and
For the positive volume , contraction gives and . Both two-forms are closed by the displayed structure equations, so the Cartan formula for the Lie derivative gives .
The product rule for divergence now yields
The vertical vector field of a surface unit tangent bundle fixes the base point and satisfies , . Since depends only on the base point,
This is the divergence of a Gaussian thermostat. Reversing the overall sign of the chosen volume form does not change its divergence, so the answer is also valid if Liouville volume is written as the oppositely oriented contact volume.
Fix an orientation and a positive volume form . Define the divergence by the Lie derivative
A smooth function is a flow coboundary when it equals for some smooth . Every other positive volume form is for a smooth . The product rule for the Lie derivative gives
Thus changing the reference volume form changes its divergence by a flow coboundary. If volume forms of either orientation are allowed, take the logarithm of the absolute ratio on each connected component; multiplying a reference form by a constant sign leaves its divergence unchanged.
If , the preceding product rule shows
Conversely, if is invariant, then is a flow coboundary. Vanishing of the Lie derivative is equivalent to flow invariance, since . Hence
The equivalence holds for every choice of reference volume form, proving the invariant volume criterion for a smooth flow. The smoothness requirement matters: a merely measurable transfer function does not give a smooth invariant volume form.
Let be the horizontal lift of supplied by the canonical coframe of a surface unit tangent bundle. The frame has commutators
Since , the Lie bracket product rule gives
These formulas hold for every smooth , with no curvature or Anosov assumption.
Follow a tangent variation and express it in the moving frame as
Pulling this identity back by makes its left side constant. The derivative of the pulled-back frame vector is the pulled-back bracket , so the coefficients satisfy
This derives the linearized transverse equation for a surface thermostat; its first equation in disappears on the quotient by .
Near a vertical plane, , and the smooth projective coordinate describes the plane as
The vertical Maslov cycle of a surface thermostat is exactly . Differentiating the quotient with the derived equations yields
Consequently
Since is a local defining function for the hypersurface, the nonzero normal derivative proves that the lifted vector field is transverse to the Maslov cycle everywhere. In particular, the sign follows from the forward derivative lift and the positive vertical-rotation convention, rather than from an unspecified projective orientation.
Use the derivative to transport the planes:
The derivative is an invertible linear map, so it sends a two-dimensional subspace to a two-dimensional subspace. The flow identity gives
Hence a plane containing the generator is sent to another plane containing the generator; the displayed formula is a well-defined smooth lift to . The chain rule gives , and is the identity. Thus it is a genuine lifted smooth flow, with inverse , rather than merely a family of maps of individual fibres. Its generator is .
Let be the unit tangent bundle projection. Write for the geodesic flow generator and for the vertical vector field of a surface unit tangent bundle, positively rotating toward . The acceleration prescribed in the question changes only this velocity angle, so the surface thermostat generator is
It never vanishes: . Also and are linearly independent, since .
The vertical Maslov cycle of a surface thermostat is
There is exactly one such plane in each fibre, so is the image of a smooth section. A two-plane containing corresponds to a line in the rank-two quotient ; thus is a projective bundle with fibre . Its total dimension is four and the cycle has dimension three, making it a smooth hypersurface. In this two-dimensional transverse space the Maslov cycle means the projective line meeting the distinguished vertical line, which here is just that distinguished line itself in each fibre.
Let be the common boundary distance function, with . For each metric, the simple Riemannian manifold property gives a unique unit-speed geodesic from to , smoothly depending on the endpoint pair. Denote its initial and terminal velocities by .
The first variation of geodesic energy, or equivalently length variation at unit speed, gives the endpoint formula
For completeness, if is an endpoint variation along a geodesic, differentiating its length and integrating the covariant derivative by parts gives
The integral vanishes by the geodesic equation, leaving precisely these two boundary terms and their opposite signs.
Because the full metrics agree on the boundary tangent spaces , the induced boundary metric , unit spheres and inward unit normals agree there. The displayed covectors therefore determine the same tangential velocity components for the two metrics:
Their normal components are fixed by unit length and the entry or exit sign. With inward unit normals ,
Strict convexity makes these signs strict for distinct endpoints. Thus and for the same endpoint pair.
Now start with any strictly inward and let its exit point be . The geodesic joining to this same has the same initial velocity , so uniqueness of the geodesic equation identifies it with the trajectory launched from . Its exit velocity is also the same. Hence
This is the boundary distance determines geodesic scattering argument. The extension to outward vectors follows by the inverse scattering relation, and tangential vectors are fixed for both metrics. Equality of the travel times follows as well, since both equal .
First recover the induced boundary metric from the boundary distance function. If is a smooth boundary curve with and , the local metric expansion of distance gives
One can obtain this expansion in local coordinates from the fact that the metric tends uniformly to its value at ; distances to nearby points have that constant metric's first-order norm. Equality of the two boundary distance functions makes the two quadratic values equal for every boundary-tangent . Polarization therefore recovers the full bilinear induced metric:
This does not yet identify the metrics on normal vectors or mixed tangent-normal pairs.
Let be the inward unit normal for . The boundary normal coordinates
are collar neighborhoods for a common sufficiently small . The Gauss lemma gives with . Hence the local boundary-fixing map already satisfies
because both pulled-back metrics there are .
To justify a global diffeomorphism, rather than assume a local collar map extends, interpolate the positive metrics by , . Their inward unit normals and exponential maps give smoothly varying collars
Compactness of gives a uniform collar size after shrinking . On the image of each collar define the time-dependent vector field
Multiply it by a smooth cutoff which is one for small and zero before the collar's outer edge, and extend it by zero to the rest of . This gives a smooth global time-dependent vector field. It vanishes on the boundary, because for all . Its flow exists for the full interval and fixes the boundary. For sufficiently small fixed , the curve solves this flow equation, so uniqueness gives
Here and . Thus the final map agrees with the local map from the collar to the collar near the boundary. In particular fixes tangential vectors and sends to there. Since the tangent-normal splittings are orthogonal and the normals have unit length,
The construction only needs equality of the induced boundary metrics; the equal-distance hypothesis supplies that equality.
A simple Riemannian manifold has strictly convex boundary, no conjugate points, and a unique connecting geodesic depending smoothly on its endpoints. In particular its unit-speed geodesics are nontrapping. Write for the inward unit normal, and identify inward and outward parts of its boundary unit tangent bundle by
The signs are a convention; here means inward. If is strictly inward, let be its first exit time. The geodesic scattering relation is
Thus it records both the exit point and the outward unit velocity, not just the exit point. On strictly outward vectors extend by following the same geodesic flow backwards to its previous entry point, retaining the velocity orientation. On tangential vectors set . The extended scattering relation is an involution on the full boundary unit bundle, since its forward and backward constructions undo one another. On a simple Riemannian manifold, the travel time equals the boundary distance function between the two endpoints; travel time is often recorded separately as lens data.
No: the round sphere supplies a counterexample. On the unit round , restrict the smooth one-form
The antipodal map satisfies , since is unchanged and changes sign. Every unit-speed closed geodesic is a great circle, with . Therefore its two half-circle integrals cancel:
The same holds for all repeated traversals and either orientation.
However, its exterior derivative is
which is not zero on the sphere. For example, at the tangent vectors and give . Hence is not a closed differential form, and cannot be an exact differential form, because . This is the counterexample to geodesic one-form injectivity on the round sphere; periodic geodesic integrals alone do not imply exactness without an additional geometric hypothesis.
Evaluate the smooth one-form on unit velocities to obtain . Its integral along a periodic orbit of the geodesic flow is exactly the one-form integral along the corresponding closed geodesic. Negative curvature makes this geodesic flow an Anosov flow; the geodesic flow of a connected closed negatively curved surface is also topologically transitive. Apply the smooth Livšic theorem to obtain with
If there is more than one connected component, apply this argument to each component separately.
The vertical vector field of a surface unit tangent bundle differentiates rotation of , so
For each , writing shows explicitly that
The fibre disintegration of Liouville volume of a surface geodesic flow is . Integrating the displayed equality over the base therefore gives . Substitution into the supplied Pestov identity for a geodesic flow yields
Both terms are nonnegative and . Thus everywhere. Since every unit-circle fibre is connected, is independent of velocity and descends to a smooth function on : . Its geodesic derivative is
Comparison with , first on unit vectors and then on all vectors by linearity, proves
Thus the one-form is an exact differential form. This proves the degree-one geodesic X-ray transform conclusion directly from the given integral identity and the stated smooth coboundary theorem.
The Livšic theorem says that for a topologically transitive Anosov flow on a closed manifold, a Hölder continuous function is a flow coboundary if and only if it has zero integral over every periodic orbit. In the integral formulation there is a Hölder continuous function satisfying
Equivalently, is differentiable along the flow and . The periodic obstruction is
It is necessary because the left-hand side of the coboundary identity is zero at a period. The substantive theorem is its sufficiency. For a smooth flow and smooth , the smooth regularity version gives a smooth . Two such solutions differ by a constant: their difference is flow invariant and hence constant on a dense orbit and, by continuity, everywhere. This smooth version is the one needed in part (b).
Use the Levi-Civita connection to represent a tangent vector to the unit tangent bundle at by the initial data of the Jacobi field generated by a variation of the unit-speed geodesic. The unit-speed constraint gives . Along the geodesic, write
Here is constant, while the perpendicular Jacobi field equation is
The flow direction is represented by . Consequently are coordinates on the transverse quotient. Define its nondegenerate quadratic form by . Its signature of a quadratic form is , and
Since the Gaussian curvature is strictly negative and the surface is a closed manifold, there is with . Hence
The quadratic-form criterion for an Anosov flow now proves the geodesic flow is Anosov. This is the geodesic hyperbolicity from negative Gaussian curvature argument. If the surface is not oriented, the local choice of perpendicular unit vector changes both and in sign; their product is unchanged, so the quadratic form still exists globally.
When , the perpendicular solutions are . The pure contracting data have and the pure expanding data have . In the canonical coframe of a surface unit tangent bundle, represents and represents , so
Equivalently the Anosov stable bundle consists of pairs with , and the Anosov unstable bundle consists of . The derivative multiplies these data by and , respectively, using parallel transport along the geodesic to identify the perpendicular directions. Together with they give the required invariant splitting.

Pinned article: Introduction to the OurBigBook Project

Welcome to the OurBigBook Project! Our goal is to create the perfect publishing platform for STEM subjects, and get university-level students to write the best free STEM tutorials ever.
Everyone is welcome to create an account and play with the site: ourbigbook.com/go/register. We belive that students themselves can write amazing tutorials, but teachers are welcome too. You can write about anything you want, it doesn't have to be STEM or even educational. Silly test content is very welcome and you won't be penalized in any way. Just keep it legal!
We have two killer features:
  1. topics: topics group articles by different users with the same title, e.g. here is the topic for the "Fundamental Theorem of Calculus" ourbigbook.com/go/topic/fundamental-theorem-of-calculus
    Articles of different users are sorted by upvote within each article page. This feature is a bit like:
    • a Wikipedia where each user can have their own version of each article
    • a Q&A website like Stack Overflow, where multiple people can give their views on a given topic, and the best ones are sorted by upvote. Except you don't need to wait for someone to ask first, and any topic goes, no matter how narrow or broad
    This feature makes it possible for readers to find better explanations of any topic created by other writers. And it allows writers to create an explanation in a place that readers might actually find it.
    Figure 1.
    Screenshot of the "Derivative" topic page
    . View it live at: ourbigbook.com/go/topic/derivative
  2. local editing: you can store all your personal knowledge base content locally in a plaintext markup format that can be edited locally and published either:
    This way you can be sure that even if OurBigBook.com were to go down one day (which we have no plans to do as it is quite cheap to host!), your content will still be perfectly readable as a static site.
    Figure 5. . You can also edit articles on the Web editor without installing anything locally.
    Video 3.
    Edit locally and publish demo
    . Source. This shows editing OurBigBook Markup and publishing it using the Visual Studio Code extension.
  3. https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook-media/master/feature/x/hilbert-space-arrow.png
  4. Infinitely deep tables of contents:
    Figure 6.
    Dynamic article tree with infinitely deep table of contents
    .
    Descendant pages can also show up as toplevel e.g.: ourbigbook.com/cirosantilli/chordate-subclade
All our software is open source and hosted at: github.com/ourbigbook/ourbigbook
Further documentation can be found at: docs.ourbigbook.com
Feel free to reach our to us for any help or suggestions: docs.ourbigbook.com/#contact