 Bessel two focus positions

Place a converging thin lens at coordinate $x$ between the object at $0$ and the screen at $L$. In air and the paraxial approximation, the required object and image distances are $u=x$ and $v=L-x$. The thin lens equation gives a quadratic equation:Its discriminant is $L^2-4Lf$. For $L>4f>0$, the two roots and their separation areBoth roots lie inside $(0,L)$, and both object and image distances exceed $f$. The two roots therefore describe finite real images on the screen. Exchanging the roots exchanges $u,v$; from transverse magnification $m=-v/u$,The image-height ratio between the enlarged and reduced settings is $|m_{-}|/|m_{+}|=|m_{-}{|}^2$, rather than $|m_{-}|$.

At $L=4f$, the roots coincide: $d=0$, $x=L/2=2f$, $u=v=2f$ and $m=-1$. There is one setting, not two separately measurable settings. For $0<L<4f$ the discriminant is negative, so no position between the fixed object and screen gives a sharp real image there. This does not forbid a real image elsewhere if the screen is moved. Another short proof observes that $x(L-x)$ has maximum $L^2/4$ at $x=L/2$; the focusing requirement $x(L-x)=Lf$ is possible exactly when $L\ge 4f$.