 Bochner identity for Killing vector fields

On a closed Riemannian manifold, a Killing vector field $X$ satisfies ${\nabla }^{\ast }\nabla X={\mathrm{Ric}}^{♯}X$ for the nonnegative rough Laplacian. This follows by differentiating ${\nabla }_i{X}_j+{\nabla }_j{X}_i=0$, contracting and commuting covariant derivatives; the contraction also gives $\mathrm{div}X=0$. Taking the inner product with $X$ and using integration by parts gives the displayed identity. If Ricci curvature is nonpositive, the nonnegative left side must vanish, so $X$ is a parallel vector field. In particular every Killing vector field on a closed flat Riemannian manifold is a parallel vector field.