Let be a nonidentity elementary embedding into a transitive class model of ZFC, with its set restrictions and Kunen critical sequence available. Let for . Then andThese domain and closure assumptions are essential; the assertion is not a statement about an arbitrary elementary map between arbitrary structures.[ref]
580 - Cardinal arithmetic (10) by Andrés E. Caicedo. Theorem14, image of the first fixed point above the critical point
For the combinatorial argument, choose an omega-Jónsson function : every subset of of cardinality has all possible values on its countable subsets. If belonged to , its order type would be , so would see it as a set of cardinality . Elementarity would make take every value below on its internally countable subsets. But every such subset is for a countable , since fixes countable enumerations coordinatewise. HenceThe value is omitted by that image, a contradiction. The existence of omega-Jónsson functions is the combinatorial input; the rest tracks precisely what the target model could contain.
New to topics? Read the docs here!