Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-astrophysics-course-of-the-university-of-oxford/2021/1/c/solution

An additional atomic input is needed: the total Case B recombination coefficient does not specify the number of H-alpha photons per net radiative recombination. Let , where is the effective recombination coefficient. At the approximately temperature implicit in the supplied , take . The coefficient 2.2 used later in the paper corresponds to , which we use consistently here.
For an unextinguished, fully filled Strömgren sphere with negligible central cavity, the H-alpha luminosity and observed radiative flux satisfy
Substitution eliminates and gives
Convert the angular diameter to radians: . Also . Thus
The implied hydrogen-ionizing photon production rate is . Using instead gives . These values use the printed milliarcseconds and integrated line observed radiative flux. Assuming one H-alpha photon per recombination would give a different, unjustified distance. An appreciable cavity or a nonunit filling factor must also enter the emitting volume.
The Brackett series consists of transitions ending at , at infrared wavelengths. They suffer much less interstellar extinction than H-alpha, so their corrected observed radiative fluxes can give a more reliable version of the same inference. At fixed measured angular size and number density, the formula has : uncorrected interstellar extinction therefore makes this particular distance estimate too small. Infrared lines are weaker and need their own effective recombination coefficients; their advantage is reduced sensitivity to dust.

New to topics? Read the docs here!