 Solution

Use a basal resource $X_1$, herbivore $X_2$ and predator $X_3$, with positive encounter, conversion and mortality parameters:Only the resource has intrinsic positive growth; the consumers die without food. There is no resource carrying capacity, immigration or feeding on nonadjacent levels. These assumptions define the simplest food chain with Lotka-Volterra equations.

A positive equilibrium would require both $X_2=r/a_1$ and $X_2=d_3/b_2$. Hence three-level coexistence is possible only on the special balance $\kappa =b_{2}r/a_1-d_3=0$. The exact identityfollows by combining $b_{2}d\log X_1/dt$ and $a_{1}d\log X_3/dt$. It gives a useful classification rather than incorrectly postulating a generic coexistence fixed point.

If $\kappa <0$, the top predator cannot invade the underlying resource-herbivore cycle: its average per-capita growth there is $\kappa$. This extinction statement can be strengthened. The boundary equilibrium has $X_{1\ast }=d_2/b_1$, $X_{2\ast }=r/a_1$, $X_{3\ast }=0$. With weights $w_1=1$, $w_2=a_1/b_1$, $w_3=a_1{a}_2/(b_1{b}_2)$, defineDirect cancellation of paired trophic terms gives $\dot{V}=w_3\kappa X_3<0$. Its level sets bound the first two species above and away from zero and bound $X_3$. Integration and uniform continuity imply $X_3\to 0$; the limiting dynamics are the usual resource-herbivore closed orbits, not generally an attracting equilibrium.

If $\kappa =0$, there is a line of positive equilibria: $X_2=r/a_1$, $b_1{X}_1-a_2{X}_3=d_2$. Choosing any positive point on that line gives a conserved coercive version of $V$ with all three relative-entropy terms. Together with the product integral, it confines generic trajectories to closed curves, with neutral oscillations around the equilibrium line. All three can persist, but only under this finely balanced parameter condition.

If $\kappa >0$, the product identity grows without bound, so at least one of $X_1,X_3$ must become unbounded in the unregulated model. There is no bounded persistent three-species attractor. Finite-time blow-up is excluded by a weighted total-abundance bound whose encounter terms cancel and whose derivative is at most a constant times that abundance. The unbounded long-term behavior signals the missing biological resource regulation. The simplest odd chain does not generically permit bounded full coexistence; adding resource self-limitation changes this conclusion.