Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2007/ii/paper-3/21g/solution

The Arzelà-Ascoli theorem for states that a family has compact closure in the uniform norm exactly when it is uniformly bounded and equicontinuous. To prove sufficiency, choose a countable dense set. From any sequence of functions, successive subsequence extraction at each dense point and a diagonal selection give convergence at all those points. Given , equicontinuity gives a common ; cover the interval by finitely many -balls centered at dense points. On a sufficiently late tail the functions differ by less than at those finitely many centres, and equicontinuity makes each of the other two differences less than . Thus the selected subsequence is uniformly Cauchy. Completeness of gives a continuous uniform limit. In a metric space this proves compactness of the closure. Conversely, a compact family has finite uniform -nets. The finitely many net functions are bounded and uniformly continuous; approximation by them gives a common bound and equicontinuity for the family. This proves both directions.
For , a positive interior maximum would have and , contradicting . A negative interior minimum likewise contradicts . The endpoint bounds therefore give everywhere.
Now put . Differentiating the equation, using the stipulated third derivative, gives . At an interior extremum of , , so . The same maximum/minimum argument and the derivative endpoint bounds imply . Consequently by the mean value theorem. Thus is uniformly bounded and equicontinuous, and the theorem makes it relatively compact, hence totally bounded in . Its closure need not be asserted to remain thrice differentiable.

New to topics? Read the docs here!