 Solution

The characteristic polynomials of a linear multistep method areExpanding the exponential-symbol order criterion for a multistep method givesThus the formal local consistency order is two for $\alpha \ne 2$, and three at $\alpha =2$, since the fourth-degree coefficient there is $-1/12$. This exceptional formal order is degenerate: ${\rho }^{\prime }(1)=\sigma (1)=0$, so it is not a convergent third-order time integrator.

For zero-stability, factor $\rho (\zeta )=(\zeta -1)(\zeta -(\alpha -1))$. The root condition for a multistep method requires every root to have modulus at most one and every unit-modulus root to be simple. For real $\alpha$ it holds exactly forAt zero the second root is $-1$, simple and admissible; at two the root one is double and inadmissible. Outside the closed interval the second root has modulus greater than one. The Dahlquist equivalence theorem says that a consistent linear multistep method is convergent exactly when it is zero-stable, for a locally Lipschitz initial-value problem with consistent starting values and solvable implicit steps. Hence the displayed interval is also exactly the convergence range, and every convergent member has order two.

The common-factor cancellation defect in a multistep recurrence explains why the $\alpha =2$ exception cannot be repaired just by canceling $\zeta -1$. For $y^{\prime }=0$, its recurrence allows linear growth from a vanishing but insufficiently small starting perturbation: $y_0=0$, $y_1=\sqrt{h}$ gives $y_n=n\sqrt{h}$, diverging at a fixed positive time. Canceling the factor silently imposes an additional starting relation and changes the method.