 Solution

Let $u=A^{\ast }h$ be the strict dual certificate for basis pursuit supplied by condition (ii). For $0\ne v\in \ker A$, we haveHere the adjoint operator is the real transpose. The injectivity of $A_S$ ensures $v_{S^c}\ne 0$: otherwise $A_S{v}_S=0$ would force $v=0$. Thus at least one nonzero term lies outside the support of a vector $x$. Since $|u_l|<1$ at every such index,This proves the fixed-sign null space condition, so part (a) gives uniqueness in basis pursuit. If $S^c$ is empty, the injectivity of $A_S=A$ instead means there is no nonzero null space vector, and the feasible set is a singleton. Injective active columns and a strict dual certificate for basis pursuit ensure unique recovery. Both ingredients matter: strictness outside $S$ cannot detect a nonzero null space direction supported entirely inside $S$.