Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2018/iii/paper-103/1/ii/solution

The Young permutation module is the symmetric-group subset permutation representation on the -element subsets of : the second row of a tabloid specifies the subset. For , restriction of a character to fixing splits these subsets into two orbits of a group action, according as they contain .
The corresponding permutation representations are on the -subsets and the -subsets of . Their Young permutation modules have two row sizes and , respectively. Sort each pair into decreasing order and omit any zero part; swapping the two row labels gives an isomorphic permutation representation. This sorting matters at .
We use Young's rule: over the complex numbers, the multiplicity of in is the Kostka number , and it can be nonzero only if dominates in the dominance order on partitions. Since each above has at most two parts and size , dominance gives
Thus has at most two nonzero parts. The character inner product measures this constituent multiplicity, so
If , the original and restricted modules are the trivial representations, giving the same conclusion. For , there is no partition of with three parts, so the assertion is vacuous.

New to topics? Read the docs here!