 Solution

A regular sonic point must make both sides of the flow equation vanish:Substituting into the Bernoulli equation yieldsFor $\gamma >1$, positive finite sound speed therefore requires the critical adiabatic index for dipolar accretionTo check that this gives real regular crossings, differentiate the flow equation at the sonic point and put $x=r_s{v}_s^{\prime }/c_s$. The transonic accretion in a power-law tube calculation givesThe minus sign gives the transonic branch whose Mach number increases inward. At $\gamma =7/5$ the positive-energy reservoir cannot match a finite sonic point; for larger $\gamma$ the required $c_s^2$ is negative. A physical surface-crossing solution also requires $r_s>R_{\star }$ and validity of the narrow flux tube approximation up to the sonic region.