Solution

ID: past-exam-of-the-mathematics-course-of-the-year-2-of-the-natural-sciences-course-of-the-university-of-cambridge/2012/paper-2/8/solution

The group order is the number of elements of the finite group. A normal subgroup satisfies for every , equivalently its left and right cosets agree.
For the square, let be counterclockwise rotation by , and reflection in the horizontal axis. The dihedral group is
The first four elements rotate by degrees. The other four are Euclidean reflections in the horizontal axis, the line , the vertical axis and the line , respectively, for a square centred at the origin with sides parallel to the axes.
The eight nontrivial proper subgroups are
To check completeness, Lagrange's theorem allows proper orders one, two and four. The order-two subgroups are generated by the five involutions displayed. An order-four subgroup containing or is the rotation subgroup. Otherwise it must contain reflections; their product is a rotation, which must be , so its reflections differ by that half-turn, giving the two listed Klein subgroups. The trivial subgroup is an additional proper subgroup. Thus the PDF's count of eight uses “proper” to exclude the trivial subgroup; with the usual inclusive definition there are nine proper subgroups.
A normal subgroup of order two is central: conjugation fixes its identity and must also fix its only other member. The half-turn commutes with every square symmetry, whereas the reflection subgroups are exchanged by conjugation. Hence the unique order-two normal subgroup is
For the general polygon, write with and . A rotation commutes with exactly when , or . A reflection cannot commute with when , because
Therefore the center of a group here is for odd , and for even . The order-two normal subgroups correspond exactly to nonidentity central involutions, proving
This agrees with the involutions in an even dihedral group and uses the convention throughout.

New to topics? Read the docs here!