 Solution

Sulfuric acid produces corrosive injury, white phosphorus can cause early gastrointestinal illness followed by delayed systemic poisoning, and strychnine produces painful, stimulus-sensitive muscle spasms. The three patterns should be distinguished rather than treated as one syndrome. “Sulphuric acid” and “strychnia” are the historical spellings used in the examination.

With swallowed sulfuric acid, the principal symptoms are immediate burning pain in the mouth, throat and upper abdomen; excessive salivation; painful or difficult swallowing; and repeated vomiting, which may contain blood. Injury to the larynx can cause swelling, altered voice and obstruction of the airway. Severe gastrointestinal damage can lead to hemorrhage, perforation and circulatory shock. The extent of injury depends on concentration, quantity and contact, so no single appearance of the mouth measures the whole injury. Inhalation of acid mist principally causes irritation, coughing, chest tightness and difficulty breathing; severe exposure can damage the lungs. These are effects of a corrosive substance at its contact sites, not the symptoms of a selectively acting convulsant.^[ref]

For phosphorus poisoning, the relevant toxic material is white phosphorus, also called yellow phosphorus. It should not be confused with ordinary dietary phosphate or assumed to have the same properties as red phosphorus. After ingestion there may be burning discomfort, thirst, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain and diarrhoea. A garlic-like odour or luminescent vomit can be a clue, but their absence does not exclude exposure. Severe cases can collapse early. More deceptively, symptoms may improve for an interval before renewed illness, jaundice, tender enlargement of the liver, abnormal bleeding, kidney injury, confusion and coma. This sequence reflects delayed systemic injury, especially liver failure; apparent recovery from the first gastric symptoms is not proof that poisoning has ended.^[ref]

Exposure of the skin or eyes to burning white phosphorus can cause severe local burns and also systemic toxicity. Long-term industrial exposure with destructive jaw disease is a different presentation from the acute swallowed-poison pattern. Current institutional toxicology distinguishes these routes and time courses; an 1865 symptom description should not be stretched into a claim that all substances containing phosphorus behave alike.^[ref]

With strychnine poisoning, apprehension, restlessness and muscular stiffness are followed by repeated, intensely painful generalized muscle spasms. Slight touch, noise, light or movement can provoke an attack. The limbs become rigid and the trunk may arch backwards in opisthotonus; jaw closure and facial contraction can give trismus and risus sardonicus. The respiratory muscles may be fixed during an attack, causing difficulty breathing and cyanosis. Between attacks there may be substantial relaxation, while consciousness is initially preserved. The person can therefore be lucid and terrified of another attack. Exhaustion, overheating and ultimately respiratory failure can follow.^[ref]

Repeated violent contractions may produce hyperthermia, acidosis and rhabdomyolysis, with dark urine and acute kidney injury. Initial awareness is characteristic, but advanced hypoxia can abolish it. The pattern differs from the immediate destructive pain of sulfuric acid and the often delayed organ injury of white phosphorus. The modern account of inhibitory glycine receptor blockade explains the stimulus-sensitive contractions, but that receptor mechanism is later knowledge, not something to attribute to an 1865 candidate.^[ref][ref]