 Typesetting penalty

A typesetting penalty expresses how desirable a candidate break is. In the Knuth-Plass line-breaking algorithm's paragraph representation, a penalty item can also have a width that is included only if that break is taken. This lets the model account for a hyphen introduced by hyphenation without printing it in the unbroken word.^[ref]

For example, suppose the material before an optional break uses 29 units and taking the break introduces a hyphen of width 2. At a typesetting line width of 30, the broken line needs $29+2=31$ units before any permitted adjustment of typesetting glue. Testing only the pre-hyphen width would wrongly declare it a fit. A finite penalty can discourage a break while still leaving it available when other choices are worse.

In TeX, values $p\ge 10000$ prohibit a penalty break and $p\le -10000$ force it. Intermediate positive values discourage and negative values encourage it. These are control conventions of the implementation, not physical lengths.^[ref]

The penalty value is an input to the typesetting demerit calculation. It is not the entire paragraph cost: typesetting badness, line-breaking fitness classes and consecutive hyphenated breaks can contribute too. Comparing two penalties alone therefore cannot choose the best text paragraph layout.