OurBigBook About$ Donate
 Sign in Sign up

Why do the electron and the proton have the same charge except for the opposite signs?

Ciro Santilli (@cirosantilli, 37) ... Standard Model Subatomic particle Elementary particle Lepton Electron Elementary charge
Updated 2025-07-16  0 By others on same topic  0 Discussions Create my own version
physics.stackexchange.com/questions/21753/why-do-electron-and-proton-have-the-same-but-opposite-electric-charge
Given the view of the Standard Model where the electron and quarks are just completely separate matter fields, there is at first sight no clear theoretical requirement for that.
As mentioned e.g. at QED and the men who made it: Dyson, Feynman, Schwinger, and Tomonaga by Silvan Schweber (1994) chapter 1.6 "Hole theory", Dirac initially wanted to think of the holes in his hole theory as the protons, as a way to not have to postulate a new particle, the positron, and as a way to "explain" the proton in similar terms. Others however soon proposed arguments why the positron would need to have the same mass, and this idea had to be discarded.

 Ancestors (11)

  1. Elementary charge
  2. Electron
  3. Lepton
  4. Elementary particle
  5. Subatomic particle
  6. Standard Model
  7. Particle physics
  8. Physics
  9. Natural science
  10. Science
  11.  Home

 View article source

 Discussion (0)

New discussion

There are no discussions about this article yet.

 Articles by others on the same topic (0)

There are currently no matching articles.
  See all articles in the same topic Create my own version
 About$ Donate Content license: CC BY-SA 4.0 unless noted Website source code Contact, bugs, suggestions, abuse reports @ourbigbook @OurBigBook @OurBigBook