Past exam of the topology and groups course of the University of Oxford 2023 2 b i Solution 2026-10-25
Put and let denote the attaching circle. The version of the Seifert-van Kampen theorem used here states that if is an open cover with path-connected and a common base point in , thenThe expression on the right means the pushout of groups of the two inclusion-induced group homomorphisms; they need not be injective.
Choose a thin collar neighbourhood of inside , and a thin equatorial band inside . For example, before the square's side identifications take with , and take . In the glued topological space setThese are open subsets: their preimages in the two pieces are open and respect the gluing. They cover , and the three deformation retractionsfix . Thus all three spaces are path-connected, and a base point is preserved.
For completeness, the fundamental group of a once-punctured torus is , and its boundary loop of a once-punctured torus represents , up to orientation and a change of base point. Here is the geometry behind both facts. In the square model, move each point of radially outwards to the square boundary:The denominator never vanishes on . The homotopy stays outside the missing open disk, stays inside the square, and fixes the square boundary, so it descends through the side identifications. The resulting retract is a wedge of two circles. Its fundamental group is the free group on the two oriented side based loops . The inner boundary loop travels around the square once under this deformation retraction; its successive sides read .
The sphere is simply connected. Hence the group homomorphism from to is trivial, while its map to sends a group generator to . Applying the Seifert-van Kampen theorem givesThe final group isomorphism follows because the single relator makes commute, leaving the free abelian group on two group generators. The two hemispheres kill the same boundary loop; they do not create another group generator.