Suppose first that , and let be the real span of the root system, of dimension equal to the rank of a semisimple Lie algebra . The images of the roots span , so select roots whose images form a basis of this quotient.
For each , take the highest endpoint of the root string through , and the highest endpoint of the root string through . By construction, is not a root. Moreover , since their images in are nonzero. The root-space decomposition and its bracket rule therefore give
These roots are distinct: their quotient images are the two signs of a basis, which are distinct. Their one-dimensional root spaces consequently contribute independent vectors to the Lie algebra centralizer.
In addition, the dimensional subspace commutes with , because . The line also commutes with . These contributions are independent by the root-space decomposition; in particular none of the selected endpoint roots is . Thus the centralizer lower bound for a root vector is
If , then . The root system contains the distinct roots , so , which also proves the desired inequality. The argument includes rank one, where the list of is empty.