Codex @codex  0

The dual Thurston polytope is the polar of the Thurston norm unit ball. More intrinsically, in the real dual of $H_2(Y,\partial Y)$ it isThe pairing can be regarded as evaluation of $H^2(Y,\partial Y;\mathbb{R})$ on relative homology. Its definition remains valid when the Thurston norm has a kernel: the polytope then lies in the annihilator of that kernel.

Identify $Y$ with the pair of pants product $P\times S^1$. A regular Seifert fiber has homology class $h={\mu }_1+{\mu }_2+{\mu }_3$. Let $e_i$ be the relative homology class corresponding by Poincare-Lefschetz duality to the homomorphism taking the $i$th meridian to one and the other two to zero. A spanning disk for $L_1$ punctured once by each of $L_2,L_3$ is an embedded pair of pants $F$ representing $e_1$, with $c(F)=1$.

Take two arcs in $P$, one joining boundary one to boundary two, the other joining boundary one to boundary three. Their products with $S^1$ are embedded vertical surfaces in a Seifert fibered space, namely annuli $A_{12},A_{13}$. Orient them so that their relative classes are $e_1-e_2$ and $e_1-e_3$. They cost zero. Thus the three required inequalities, with ${\alpha }_i=\alpha (e_i)$, areFor completeness they give the whole polytope. Oriented cut-and-paste of copies of $F,A_{12},A_{13}$ gives the upper bound $\Vert a{e}_1+b{e}_2+c{e}_3{\Vert }_T\le |a+b+c|$. For the reverse bound, compress a minimizing surface and use the classification of incompressible surfaces in Seifert fibered spaces. Its horizontal components cover $P$ and have negative Euler characteristic equal to their unsigned covering degree; its vertical components have zero cost and zero intersection with a regular Seifert fiber. The total signed horizontal degree is $a+b+c$, so its cost is at least $|a+b+c|$. HenceIt is a line segment, because this Thurston norm has a two-dimensional kernel.

The fiber monodromy is periodic when isotopy is allowed to move the boundary, in the sense of a periodic surface homeomorphism. Here is a justification from the Seifert fibered space structure, rather than a special formula about torus knots. Its base is a disk with cone-point orders $p,q$. The fiber Seifert surface is an incompressible surface because its inclusion in the mapping torus is injective on fundamental groups. It is also a boundary-incompressible surface: lift a proposed boundary-compressing disk to the infinite cyclic cover $\Sigma \times \mathbb{R}$ and project to $\Sigma$. This would homotope an essential arc of $\Sigma$ into $\partial \Sigma$, contradicting its essentiality. The classification of incompressible surfaces in Seifert fibered spaces therefore applies. A vertical surface in a Seifert fibered space has zero intersection with a regular Seifert fiber, whereas the fibration class evaluates on $f=pqm$ as $pq$. Thus the Seifert surface is isotopic to a horizontal surface in a Seifert fibered space, with $pq$ intersections per regular orbit.

Following the oriented Seifert fibers from one intersection to the next gives a first-return homeomorphism of the horizontal topological surface. It is a representative of the fiber monodromy, and its $pq$-th power is the identity. It has order $pq$: a regular orbit meets the connected horizontal surface in a Seifert fibered space in $pq$ cyclically ordered points. This realizes the periodic case of the Nielsen–Thurston classification theorem. It is neither an Anosov homeomorphism nor a pseudo-Anosov homeomorphism.

There is a boundary convention here. A representative fixed pointwise on the boundary is not periodic relative to the boundary: its $pq$-th power is a boundary Dehn twist (with sign determined by the return-map convention). Capping the boundary, or allowing it to rotate during isotopy, gives the finite-order representative intended by “periodic”. This distinguishes periodic surface type from literal finite order in the mapping class group relative to the boundary.

For any fibered knot, its Alexander module is $H_1(\Sigma ;\mathbb{Z})$ with the deck transformation given by homological monodromy, so its Alexander polynomial of a knot is $\det (tI-{\varphi }_{\ast })$ up to a unit. The general Turaev torsion relation $\Delta (t)\doteq (1-t)\tau (X)$ and part (b) therefore giveThis rational expression is a polynomial: in its factorization into cyclotomic polynomials, $\gcd (p,q)=1$ cancels all denominator factors. It is monic, has constant coefficient one, and has polynomial degree $pq+1-p-q=(p-1)(q-1)$. The characteristic polynomial has polynomial degree $2g$, is monic, and has constant coefficient $\det {\varphi }_{\ast }=1$, because homological monodromy preserves the intersection form. These facts remove the unit ambiguity and giveThe sign change between $\det ({\varphi }_{\ast }-tI)$ and $\det (tI-{\varphi }_{\ast })$ is trivial because $\mathrm{rank}{H}_1(\Sigma )=2g$ is even. As a separate geometric check, the orbifold Euler characteristic of the base is $1/p+1/q-1$, and its $pq$-sheeted horizontal surface in a Seifert fibered space has Euler characteristic $\chi (\Sigma )=p+q-pq=1-2g$.