Put , take odd , and let be the index- multiplicative subgroup. If a -set has its unordered pair differences in distinct -cosets, choose containing exactly one element from each pair . Then is a difference family for a Steiner 2-design. Indeed one unordered pair supplies each coset, and its two difference orientations multiplied by cover that coset once. Translations yield a - Steiner system. The cyclotomic pattern extension by a second-moment bound supplies suitable for all sufficiently large in this progression.
Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2002 iii Paper 11 1 i Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Use the pair-design convention: each pair of distinct points must lie in exactly one Steiner block of size . With this convention the printed endpoint is false for every , since a singleton contains no pair. Thus the intended assertion requires . For , take all pairs as Steiner blocks for any . We now give a finite-field construction for every fixed , without assuming the desired design-existence theorem.
Put and take an odd prime power . By cyclicity of , it has a subgroup of index ; its order is even, so . We will find a -set such that its unordered pair differences occupy the distinct cyclotomic classes of a finite field modulo . The following argument supplies that set for every sufficiently large compatible .
First establish the required two-class intersection estimate by elementary character sums. Let be a multiplicative character of a finite field of order , with for a generator . Extend every power , including the trivial character, by zero at zero. For ,For a nontrivial additive character of and a nontrivial multiplicative character , its Gauss sum of a finite-field character satisfiesHere the inner sum equals for and otherwise, by additive-character orthogonality; multiplicative-character orthogonality gives the last equality. Such a nontrivial additive character exists by identifying the additive group with a vector space over its prime field and choosing a nonzero linear functional into that prime field.
If are nontrivial, substituting , in the product of their Gauss sums provesThe terms with sum to zero because is nontrivial. Hence . If exactly one character is trivial, subtracting the excluded zero and one terms gives absolute value one. If both are nontrivial but their product is trivial, the substitution gives , again of absolute value one. If both are trivial, the sum is . Expanding the two cyclotomic indicators and scaling a nonzero translate to one therefore gives, uniformly in and ,All constants depend only on the fixed .
To extend a prescribed difference pattern on coordinates, fix desired classes for the new differences and setAverage over all tuples, allowing repeated coordinates just for this average. With , counting choices for each independently givesFor the second moment, sum over the two potential extensions . The terms contribute . For , the choices of number each, by the preceding intersection estimate. ThusThe Chebyshev inequality shows that the proportion of tuples with is . Inductively, any fixed compatible difference pattern on distinct coordinates is realized by at least tuples, with independent of sufficiently large . The assertion starts with . Almost all tuples are outside the exceptional set, so at least half the realizing tuples have at least extensions. Each extension is distinct from the old coordinates because its differences belong to nonzero classes. This proves the assertion for . This cyclotomic pattern extension by a second-moment bound avoids the false assumption that every partial choice can be extended.
Prescribe a different one of the cosets to each pair , . Since , changing an orientation does not change its coset, so the prescriptions are compatible. The preceding induction supplies .
Choose containing one element from each pair . Form the Steiner blocksFor two distinct points , their difference identifies exactly one unordered pair of having the same -coset. Exactly one of and its negative lies in . Choose the orientation of that pair making , and then set . This yields , . Both the oriented base pair and are unique, so precisely one Steiner block contains the pair. In particular different Steiner block parameters cannot produce repeated Steiner blocks. Equivalently, the Steiner blocks form a difference family for a Steiner 2-design, and translation gives the cyclotomic construction of a Steiner 2-design.
There are infinitely many suitable field orders: choose one odd prime not dividing , and take for integers . Euler's congruence gives , and these orders become arbitrarily large. ConsequentlyThe qualification at is necessary for the standard pair-design definition.