Exactly one lowest-numbered ball is selected in each occupied bin, so
Part c supplies the corresponding one-sided coordinate certificate. The product-space entropy method for certifiable functions states that a function with such a certificate of squared size at most has both centered tails bounded by . Taking gives
The lower-tail form of the entropy method for certifiable functions states that a unit-bounded-difference, -certifiable nonnegative integer-valued function satisfies
It follows by applying entropy tensorization to a minimal certificate: only its at most coordinates can contribute to the one-sided variance proxy, and changing any one contributes at most one.
The Chernoff bound therefore gives
Choosing proves
Tensorization of entropy Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-09-24
For a nonnegative function of independent random variables, entropy is at most the sum of its conditional coordinate entropies. This tensorization is a basic step of the entropy method.