Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2013 iii Paper 2 1 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-07
Put and let be the integral closure of in . We first establish the elementary integral extension machinery, and then use the trace pairing to put inside a finite -module.
An integral element satisfies a monic polynomial over the base ring. If its equation has degree , the powers generate as an -module. More generally, adjoining finitely many integral elements gives a finitely generated module: reduce the exponent of each generator using its monic equation. Conversely, if an -submodule of an extension algebra contains , is finitely generated, and is stable under multiplication by , choose generators and write . Multiplying by its adjugate shows that its monic determinant annihilates every , hence annihilates . This finite-module criterion for integrality is the determinant trick.
If are integral elements, the finite -module is stable under , and . The criterion proves that these are integral elements. Thus the integral closure really is a subring. It also proves integral dependence is transitive: if is integral over an integral -algebra , take the finitely many coefficients of its equation, form their finite -subalgebra , and observe that is finite over and therefore finite over . The criterion applies to . In particular, an algebra generated by finitely many integral elements is a finite integral extension, even though an arbitrary integral extension need not be finite.
Choose a -basis of . Each basis element is algebraic over . Ifchoose a nonzero clearing all coefficient denominators. Then satisfies a monic equation with coefficients . Hence all belong to and still form a -basis. This is integral field basis by denominator clearing.
We next prove the trace of an integral element over a normal domain property. For , its images under all -embeddings of into an algebraic closure are integral elements over , because each satisfies the same monic equation. Their sum is integral by the subring property just proved. Since is a separable field extension, that sum is the field trace and lies in . The normality assumption means that is a normal domain, equivalently an integrally closed domain, soThe same conclusion applies to , since is a ring.
The trace pairing of a finite separable field extension is nondegenerate. One can see this directly using the allowed Galois theory: for a primitive element , the embedding matrix of is a Vandermonde matrix in the distinct conjugates of . Its determinant is nonzero, and the trace Gram matrix is its transpose times itself. Nondegeneracy is unchanged by a change of basis.
Let . Its trace-dual lattice isNondegeneracy supplies a trace-dual -basis , with . The coefficient formula givesEquivalently, the matrix has entries in and nonzero determinant ; if , then and the adjugate formula gives . Thus as well. Both descriptions exhibit a finite free ambient -module.
A finite -module is a Noetherian module when is a Noetherian ring, and every submodule of a Noetherian module is finitely generated. Since is an -submodule of , we obtainThis proves finiteness of integral closure in a finite separable extension. The hypotheses have distinct roles: separability makes the trace pairing nonsingular, normality puts integral traces back in , and Noetherianity makes the contained submodule finite. Also , since the integral basis elements span over , and is itself Noetherian because its ideals are -submodules of a finite -module.
First prove the finite-module criterion for integrality in a slightly stronger form, for any nonzero finitely generated -submodule stable under multiplication by . Choose generators and write with integer coefficients. Multiply the vector equation by its adjugate matrix. This gives for every generator. Some generator is nonzero and is a field, so . The polynomial is monic with integer coefficients, proving integrality of . This implication needs no prior closure theorem for .
Conversely, if satisfies a monic polynomial of degree , then is generated by and is stable under . Every also maps into itself because it is an integer polynomial in ; the finite-module criterion for integrality just proved makes every such integral. Thus this really lies in , proving the stated equivalence without circularity.
For two integral elements , the module spanned by for , contains one, is finitely generated, and is stable under both elements by their monic equations. It is therefore stable under and . The finite-module criterion for integrality proves that both are integral. Negatives follow by replacing a multiplication matrix by its negative, and are integral. Hence .
The integral basis of the cubic field of discriminant minus 140 can be obtained as follows. For the specified field, Eisenstein at two makes irreducible, and is integral because the polynomial is monic. The discriminant of a monic cubic is , soHere is the printed notation for the signed discriminant, namely the square of a Vandermonde product of the conjugates; that product need not be real.
Suppose is integral with the prescribed binary coefficients. The root traces give , , . Thus must be an integer, forcing . If , nonzeroness of the coefficient triple forces , giving . If , multiply by and use :Closure of the ring then again gives .
But , so the field norm of is . The field norm of an algebraic integer is an integer, proving . Dividing the defining cubic by gives . Thus cannot be integral either.
Finally the discriminant-index formula for an integral lattice says . The square of the integer index divides , so its only possibilities are one and four, giving index one or two. If the index were two, a nonzero coset would supply an integral element after reducing coefficients modulo two, with a nonzero binary triple. The preceding argument would force the impossible integrality of . Hence