Apply the method of multiple scales with independent fast time and slow time . A preliminary slow time produces no resonant forcing at first order, so its leading amplitudes are constant; the first nontrivial modulation is at . Write , with
At order , the inhomogeneous linear differential equation is . Absorbing its homogeneous part into the amplitudes gives
At order , the forcing is . Its resonant Fourier series coefficients are
The solvability condition in the method of multiple scales sets both coefficients to zero, giving the amplitude equations. Define
For bounded initial conditions , , the requested leading approximation is
This holds on bounded intervals of , hence , with the constant in the error allowed to depend on the bounded interval. If desired, retain the displayed and adjust by to match initial conditions at that order. No particular initial conditions were supplied.
Since , the matrix exponential is when . When , put and replace this with . At it is . Thus the leading second instability tongue of a weak Mathieu oscillator has exponentially growing solutions for , and the leading modulation is bounded for every initial condition precisely when
At either displayed endpoint, is a nonzero nilpotent operator; some initial conditions give a secular term proportional to . This leading calculation alone must not be mistaken for an exact finite- stability decision at the endpoints.
For an exact small- interpretation, put . The standard Mathieu equation parameters are and . Its two relevant Mathieu characteristic values are obtained by projecting onto even and odd Fourier series modes. Near the unperturbed value , the even modes have diagonal entries and adjacent couplings in an orthonormal basis; the odd modes have diagonal entries and couplings . Substituting into their characteristic polynomials gives
Higher modes of the Fourier series first contribute at higher order. Therefore the fourth-order edges of the second Mathieu instability tongue are
Floquet theory gives boundedness of every solution outside the closed gap, or , in this fixed- neighborhood. At the actual gap edges the second independent solution is generically unbounded. In particular, if is fixed exactly at or , it lies just outside the true gap and is stable for each sufficiently small positive . The strict boxed criterion is the robust leading-order, uniformly separated criterion; the endpoints require this higher-order refinement, and their amplification bounds need not remain uniform as .