Freiling axiom of symmetry ($A_{<{\omega }_1}(\mathbb{R})$)

Every function $f:\mathbb{R}\to [\mathbb{R}{]}^{<{\omega }_1}$ has reals $x,y$ with $x\notin f(y)$ and $y\notin f(x)$. The values are countable subsets. Requiring distinct witnesses is equivalent, by first adjoining $x$ to $f(x)$. The Freiling theorem identifies this axiom with the negation of the Continuum hypothesis in ZFC.

In ZFC, the Freiling axiom of symmetry is equivalent to failure of the Continuum hypothesis. Under the hypothesis, countable initial segments of a well-order of the reals violate symmetry. When the continuum exceeds ${\aleph }_1$, the union of the countable values on an ${\aleph }_1$-sized set leaves a real outside; avoiding that real's countable value gives the two witnesses.