Ellis–Numakura lemma Created 2026-09-28 Updated 2026-11-05
Choose an inclusion-minimal nonempty compact subsemigroup , using Zorn's lemma and the finite intersection property. For , the set is a nonempty compact subsemigroup, so minimality gives . Hence is nonempty. It is a compact closed subset of by continuity and the Hausdorff space assumption, and is a subsemigroup because for . Minimality gives , so .[ref]
Reversing multiplication gives the same conclusion for a right-topological semigroup. Joint continuity of multiplication is not needed.
An associative binary operation on a nonempty set makes a group if there is with for every , and every has some with . No left identity element or left inverse element assumption is needed. First, an idempotent element of a semigroup satisfies : choose with and compute . If , then , so by the previous observation. Finally, . Thus all group axioms follow.
Suppose . Using only associativity and the given right identity element property,
Thus is an idempotent element of a semigroup. By i it equals , proving
No left identity element or cancellation law is needed for this deduction.
Suppose . Choose with , using the given right inverse element property. Multiply the idempotent relation on the right by . By associativity and the given right identity element property,
Thus the only idempotent element of a semigroup is . This argument uses no cancellation and does not assume a left identity element.