Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2001 iii Paper 2 2 Solution Created 2026-10-03 Updated 2026-10-14
Work over , or another field of characteristic zero. The Weyl algebra is generated by with commuting 's, commuting 's and . Its ordered monomial basis of a Weyl algebra consists of the monomials . One way to verify independence is to apply a finite operator relation to the formal exponential : after canceling that exponential the relation becomes a polynomial identity , so every coefficient vanishes. The relations already reorder every word into that basis.
Give both generators degree one. The Bernstein filtration isThus . Commutator terms have lower degree, accounting for the commutative symbol algebra. Since that algebra is Noetherian, leading-symbol generation followed by finite downward degree cancellation proves that is Noetherian on both sides.
A left finitely generated module has a good filtration, for example for a finite generating set of the module. More generally one allows fixed degree shifts of the generators. The associated graded module is finite over the symbol algebra. DefineThis is the characteristic variety of a Weyl algebra module for the Bernstein algebra filtration. It records where the module's leading symbols remain nonzero and makes noncommutative module growth accessible to commutative algebra.
For a fixed algebra filtration it is independent of the good filtration. Any two such filtrations differ by bounded shifts and conversely, since each finite set of generators occurs in bounded degree in the other filtration. If a degree- operator has symbol annihilating , its th power maps into . For , bounded-shift comparison forces the power of that symbol to annihilate . Reversing the argument gives equal radicals of ideals of annihilators. This is independence of characteristic support from a good module filtration. Changing the algebra filtration itself, for example to the order filtration of a Weyl algebra with the in degree zero, need not preserve the same variety; the convention matters.
The Hilbert-Serre theorem gives an eventual cumulative polynomialHere is also the Gelfand–Kirillov dimension of a module, and is an integer multiplicity of a filtered module for nonzero . Finite generation bounds .
Here is a proof sketch of the essential lower bound, rather than an appeal to its name. For a nonzero , choose a nonzero monomial of greatest total degree in its ordered expansion, say . The operations and differentiate this expansion with respect to and . Apply them and times. Lower-degree terms die, and every other monomial of the same degree also dies unless it has exactly those exponents. The result is a nonzero scalar multiple of the chosen coefficient. Characteristic zero is essential for the factorials. Expanding the repeated commutators therefore givesChoose . If acted as zero on all , every would vanish, contrary to . Hence the linear action mapis injective. It follows that . Comparing polynomial degrees gives . ThusThis proves Bernstein inequality for Weyl algebra modules through the faithful finite-step action of a Weyl algebra.
The bound is sharp. The polynomial representation has the zero section as its characteristic variety of a Weyl algebra module, namely and dimension . It is a simple module: differentiate a nonzero polynomial sufficiently to obtain a nonzero constant, then multiply by the to generate the whole module. The module similarly has characteristic variety of a Weyl algebra module , a fiber of the cotangent bundle. A nonzero free module has the whole cotangent bundle and dimension . No nonzero finite-dimensional module exists for , also seen by taking the trace of .
Modules attaining dimension are holonomic Weyl algebra modules (with the zero module included conventionally). Every nonzero subquotient remains of dimension by the lower bound and monotonicity of growth. Compatible filtrations in a short exact sequence make the leading multiplicity of a filtered module additive. Since each nonzero factor has positive integer multiplicity of a filtered module, the number of factors in any strict submodule chain is bounded by . Together with Noetherianity, this proves finite composition length. It illustrates why characteristic variety of a Weyl algebra module and multiplicity of a filtered module provide useful structure beyond a list of presentations. In positive characteristic there are finite-dimensional Weyl modules, so the characteristic-zero inequality and this discussion must not be asserted without its field hypothesis.