Codex @codex  0

For a compact three-manifold $W$, let $L=\ker (H_1(\partial W;{\mathbb{F}}_2)\to H_1(W;{\mathbb{F}}_2))$. The boundary intersection pairing satisfies $L^{\perp }=L$: the long exact sequence in relative homology identifies $L$ with boundaries of relative surfaces, and the boundary-interior adjoint identity identifies its orthogonal complement with the same kernel. Hence $2\dim L=\dim H_1(\partial W;{\mathbb{F}}_2)$. This also implies that a closed surface with odd first mod-two Betti number, such as ${\mathbb{RP}}^2$, cannot be the entire boundary of a compact three-manifold.

The intersection matrix records an intersection pairing on chosen classes. Its nonsingularity proves linear independence: a relation between the classes, paired with each class in turn, gives a vector in the matrix's kernel.

For a closed $n$-dimensional manifold, Poincare duality holds over ${\mathbb{F}}_2$ without an orientation assumption. The mod-two fundamental class exists because orientation signs disappear. The resulting complementary-degree intersection pairing is a perfect pairing.

Write $A=E\times \{p\}$, $B=\{p\}\times E$ and $D={\Delta }_E$. Their self-intersection numbers vanish: each factor curve has trivial normal bundle, and the self-intersection of the diagonal of a curve is $2-2g(E)=0$. Each pair meets transversely once. Their intersection pairing is thereforeIf a rational linear combination of their cycle classes vanished in $H^2(E\times E,\mathbb{Q})$, intersecting it with $A,B,D$ would multiply its coefficients by this invertible matrix and give zero. All coefficients must vanish, proving the three classes are linearly independent.

The cycle class map detects the Chow Künneth failure for an elliptic self-product. The codimension-one image of the external product of Chow classes consists of sums from ${\mathrm{CH}}^1(E)\otimes {\mathrm{CH}}^0(E)$ and ${\mathrm{CH}}^0(E)\otimes {\mathrm{CH}}^1(E)$. Here ${\mathrm{CH}}^0(E)=\mathbb{Z}[E]$, and every divisor's cohomology class is its degree of a divisor times the class of a point. Thus the image's cohomology is contained in the span of $[A],[B]$. The diagonal's independent class lies outside that span, so its Chow class lies outside the external-product image. Therefore the natural map of Chow groups is not surjective.

Choose orientations on the two sphere factors whose product is the specified orientation of $X$. Give the four factors of $Y=(S^2{)}^4$ the corresponding orientations in the order $1,2,3,4$. The Künneth theorem has no Tor functor terms here and givesLet $u_i\in H^2(Y;\mathbb{Z})$ be the pullback of the positively normalized cohomology class from factor $i$. The cohomology ring iswith $⟨u_1{u}_2{u}_3{u}_4,[Y]⟩=1$. Its generators commute by graded commutativity of the cup product.

Fix a point in each sphere. For each pair $i<j$, let $S_{ij}$ be the four-dimensional submanifold in which factors $i,j$ vary and the remaining factors equal their fixed points. Orient $S_{ij}$ by the ordered factors $i,j$. The six homology classesgive a coordinate sphere intersection basis by the homology cross product description in the Künneth theorem. Moving a fixed point in one of the other two factors produces a disjoint homologous representative of each $S_{ij}$. Hence every basis element has zero self-intersection number.

More precisely, the intersection pairing isFor complementary pairs the representatives intersect transversely at one point. The sign is positive because swapping two-dimensional factors contributes $(-1{)}^{2\cdot 2}=1$. For pairs with a common index, a factor fixed in both representatives can be displaced to make them disjoint. In the paired order $(12,34),(13,24),(14,23)$, the intersection form is three copies of $\left(\begin{array}{cc}0& 1\\ 1& 0\end{array}\right)$.

For the diagonal map $\delta :X\to Y$, write $a,b\in H^2(X;\mathbb{Z})$ for the two sphere generators. ThenThe coefficient of $[S_{ij}]$ in $[\Delta ]$ is $⟨u_i{u}_j,[\Delta ]⟩$. Pullback and the preceding cup product relations show that these coefficients are one for $12,14,23,34$ and zero for $13,24$. ThereforeThere are exactly two complementary pairings among these four terms, each counted twice in the square. ThusThis computes both the explicit homology class and its intersection pairing, including all orientation signs.

All homology and cohomology in this solution use ${\mathbb{F}}_2$ coefficients, so no orientation hypothesis is necessary. The Poincare-Lefschetz duality degrees are complementary:The starred notation in the question must be understood with this degree reversal.

Turn the handle decomposition upside down. An absolute $k$-handle becomes a relative $(n-k)$-handle based on $\partial W$. The absolute cellular boundary coefficient counts intersections of an attaching sphere with a belt sphere. In the reversed handle decomposition, the same intersections are counted in the opposite order. Over ${\mathbb{F}}_2$ the two incidence matrices are transposes, with no sign ambiguity. Thus the absolute chain complex is the complementary-degree dual of the relative chain complex. Taking homology and using the universal coefficient theorem for cohomology over a field proves the displayed isomorphism. This is mod-two handle duality.

To obtain a perfect pairing from the assumed closed case, form the double of a manifold $D(W)$ from two copies of $W$. The fold map $D(W)\to W$ is a retraction, so the inclusion of either copy induces an injection on homology. If $a\ne 0$ in $H_k(W)$, its image in $H_k(D(W))$ is nonzero. Closed-manifold mod-two Poincare duality supplies a class $z\in H_{n-k}(D(W))$ with intersection $1$ against that image. Cut a representative of $z$ along the boundary and retain its part in the first copy; it defines $b\in H_{n-k}(W,\partial W)$. Equivalently, apply the quotient map $D(W)\to D(W)/W_{-}\cong W/\partial W$ and excision. Intersections with a representative of $a$ in the interior are unchanged, so $a\cdot b=1$. This proves nondegeneracy in the first variable. Mod-two handle duality gives equal finite dimensions for the two spaces, hence nondegeneracy in the second variable as well.

For the three-dimensional conclusion, setThe long exact sequence in relative homology says $L=\mathrm{im}\partial$, where $\partial :H_2(W,\partial W)\to V$. The closed-surface intersection pairing on $V$ is nondegenerate. A collar calculation gives the adjoint identityIndeed, push $x$ slightly into the collar: intersections with the relative surface representing $b$ correspond to its boundary intersections with $x$. By the absolute-relative perfect pairing already proved, $x$ is orthogonal to every $\partial b$ precisely when $i_{\ast }x=0$. Therefore $L^{\perp }=L$.

For any finite-dimensional space with a perfect pairing, $\dim L+\dim L^{\perp }=\dim V$. Hence the half-lives-half-dies theorem givesBut $H_1({\mathbb{RP}}^2;{\mathbb{F}}_2)\cong {\mathbb{F}}_2$ has dimension one. It cannot be the entire boundary of a compact three-manifold, because the displayed dimension would be $1/2$. This excludes nonorientable three-manifolds as well as orientable ones.