Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2023 1 c Solution 2026-10-25
Suppose first that is -primary. Since is a Noetherian ring, choose a finite generating set of an ideal . The equality of radicals of ideals supplies positive integers with . SetEvery product of generators has some appearing at least times. Such products generate the product of ideals , so . Also . If , take directly.
Conversely, suppose . Taking radicals of ideals givesHence . The only maximal ideal containing is : any such maximal ideal contains and therefore equals . By the correspondence theorem for ideals, the quotient ring is a local ring with maximal ideal . Every element outside this maximal ideal is a unit.
If and , then cannot be outside , since multiplying by its inverse in the quotient ring would give . Thus and , proving the required primary ideal condition. We have proved the maximal-primary ideal criterion
Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2023 1 d Solution 2026-10-25
Put , and . The quotient ring is an integral domain, so is a prime ideal and hence a primary ideal. Put . ThenThe polynomial ring is a Noetherian ring by the Hilbert basis theorem, and is a maximal ideal since . Therefore the maximal-primary ideal criterion from c makes -primary. In particular its radical of an ideal is , distinct from .
Neither primary ideal can be omitted: , while . Thus the given intersection is already a minimal primary decomposition. To express the ideal by generators, write an element of as . Reducing modulo the prime ideal gives in the integral domain , so . Cancelling in the integral domain gives . HenceBy the first uniqueness theorem for primary decomposition, the associated primes of a module are exactly the two radicals of ideals. Their strict inclusion givesOne can also see both associated primes of a module directly through annihilators:For the first colon ideal, reducing modulo forces , and the reverse inclusion follows from . For the second colon ideal, cancel in . Both represented elements of the quotient module are nonzero.