Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge 2006 ib Paper 2 5A Solution Created 2026-09-24 Updated 2026-10-14
At a constrained stationary point where , every tangent direction to is orthogonal to . Vanishing of the directional derivative of in all such directions forces for a Lagrange multiplier . Solve these equations together with the constraint, then check the candidates and any singular or limiting cases for minima or maxima.
Let a closed cylinder have radius and height , with fixed . Its area is and the constraint is . The Lagrange multiplier equations giveThe second yields ; substituting into the first gives . Thus the minimum-area closed cylinder at fixed volume hasTo prove it is the global minimum, eliminate to obtain . Its derivative is , negative before the displayed radius and positive afterwards; the area tends to infinity both as and as . This establishes uniqueness and rules out limiting smaller areas.