Fubini-Study form from circle reduction Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-07
The scalar circle group action on with the standard symplectic form has moment map in the convention . Reduction of the radius- sphere gives Complex projective space and the form . Its area on a complex projective line is . Thus yields the Fubini-Study form normalized to projective-line area , while yields half that form. The Hopf fibration identifies the quotient.
For a symplectic left Lie group action, use actual fundamental fields and . They satisfy . Cartan's magic formula then gives . Thus every commutator generator has a globally exact contraction. A semisimple Lie algebra is perfect, so every generator has a global Hamiltonian. The separate semisimple moment-map equivariance result removes the constant two-cocycle obstruction and gives an equivariant moment map for a connected group.
Hamiltonian group action Created 2026-10-05 Updated 2026-10-14
A Hamiltonian group action is a Lie group action on a symplectic manifold with an equivariant moment map . In the sign convention , each component satisfies , where is the fundamental vector field. The opposite Hamiltonian vector field convention reverses the sign.
At a regular free circle group level of a moment map, the inverse image of a Lagrangian submanifold of the reduced space is a Lagrangian submanifold of the original space. Its restricted symplectic form is the pullback of the reduced form and hence vanishes. Its dimension is one more than that of the reduced Lagrangian, exactly half the ambient dimension. It is a circle bundle over the original Lagrangian.
Marsden-Weinstein theorem Created 2026-10-06 Updated 2026-10-14
For a Hamiltonian group action, let be a regular value of the moment map fixed by the coadjoint action, and assume the action on is free and proper. The quotient is a symplectic manifold of dimension . Its unique reduced symplectic form is characterized by , where includes the level set and is the quotient projection. The kernel of the restricted two-form consists precisely of the orbit directions. More general noncentral levels use their stabilizer group; the stated central-level version suffices for circle group reduction.
For a weakly Hamiltonian left Lie group action on a connected symplectic manifold, choose . Fundamental vector fields and Hamiltonian vector fields are both antihomomorphisms, so the displayed difference is constant. The Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket makes it a two-cocycle. Changing by changes the difference by . Thus its class in Lie algebra cohomology obstructs choosing an equivariant moment map. For a connected group, vanishing of this class gives infinitesimal and group equivariance.
A symplectic manifold is a smooth even-dimensional manifold with a differential two-form that is closed, , and nondegenerate at every point. Nondegeneracy identifies vector fields with differential one-forms by the interior product . In this solution use the explicit Hamiltonian vector field convention
This contraction sign differs from the negative-sign convention sometimes used for Hamiltonian vector fields; all subsequent signs are fixed by the displayed choice. In Darboux coordinates with it gives
The Poisson bracket is bilinear and antisymmetric, and the ordinary product rule gives . Thus it remains to check the Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket.
The Cartan formula for the Lie derivative and closedness of the symplectic form give . Hence
and nondegeneracy gives
Applying both sides to an arbitrary smooth function gives , which is exactly the Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket. Consequently the smooth functions, with their pointwise product and this Poisson bracket, form a Poisson algebra. Constants have zero Hamiltonian vector field. If are components of moment maps, the same displayed relation relates the brackets of their Hamiltonian vector fields to the Poisson bracket of those components. In the opposite contraction convention the corresponding relation is the Hamiltonian Lie algebra homomorphism with the compatible bracket sign.
For the point vortices, remove the collision diagonals from , since the logarithmic Hamiltonian function is singular there. Set for . Differentiating each pair contribution gives
The Hamiltonian vector field therefore gives the equations of motion
Each contribution is perpendicular to the displacement from vortex to vortex and has magnitude . This is the velocity induced by a point vortex of positive circulation, with the normalization . Each vortex is advected by the velocity of the others, without a self-induced singular velocity. Pairwise contributions cancel in the total velocity, so and are conserved. For two vortices the separation is constant and they rotate counterclockwise about their midpoint, as expected for identical positive point vortices.
For , compute its Poisson bracket with directly:
The last sum vanishes by pairing with , since their numerators are opposite and denominators equal. Thus Poisson commutes with and is conserved. Equivalently, the Hamiltonian function depends only on pairwise distances and is invariant under simultaneous rotations.
The standard positive generator of the simultaneous circle group action is
Its interior product with the symplectic form is
Use the moment map convention for the usual positive rotation generator. Identifying with , this proves is the moment map for the standard rotation action. It is invariant under the action, hence equivariant because circle group is abelian. Additive constants are possible; the natural normalization is at the origin of the ambient space. On the collision-free space this polynomial is its restriction. With the solution's positive contraction convention, the rotation generator is . Confusing these two signs would reverse the final augmented Hamiltonian.
Let denote simultaneous counterclockwise rotation through , and introduce the co-rotating coordinates by . Both the symplectic form and are rotation-invariant, so pulling back the inertial Hamiltonian vector field leaves unchanged. Differentiating the rotation gives the co-rotating equation
The co-rotating positions are constant precisely when this Hamiltonian vector field vanishes. By nondegeneracy of the symplectic form, that is equivalent to
Conversely a collision-free critical point of this augmented Hamiltonian function produces a rigidly rotating solution. This is a rotating point-vortex relative equilibrium.
As a sign and scaling check, scaling every position by changes by . Therefore . At a rotating point-vortex relative equilibrium, , so . For the angular velocity is positive in this circulation convention. An equilateral three-vortex configuration of circumradius has and , agreeing directly with the equations of motion.
Use and , so in the stated real coordinates and . For , let be the actual fundamental vector field of the left action, obtained by differentiating at zero. Since the action preserves , Cartan's magic formula gives .
A global component Hamiltonian requires this closed one-form to be exact, with
Choose these functions linearly in . This defines the moment map, with equivariance when the constants have the required normalization. A symplectic action alone need not admit it: translation in a periodic coordinate of a symplectic two-torus contracts to a closed one-form with nonzero period. A sufficient existence condition is ; more generally one assumes the action is weakly Hamiltonian and resolves its moment-map equivariance obstruction.
Because the group also preserves ,
The component vector fields commute with the Hamiltonian flow: in this convention , hence . These are both conserved observables and infinitesimal symmetries of the dynamics.
For a left action, fundamental vector fields obey . Together with the Hamiltonian-field identity, this makes
have zero Hamiltonian vector field. It is therefore constant on each connected component of . One sufficient condition for is an equivariant moment map, , where . Differentiating this condition along gives directly
A useful concrete sufficient condition is a common fixed point and the normalization . The constant is zero there because all fundamental fields vanish, and hence zero everywhere on connected . This is fixed-point normalization removes the moment-map cocycle. If the action has an ineffective Lie-algebra kernel, the map to observables can have that kernel; equality of brackets alone is not a claim of a faithful representation.
For the oscillator, the printed complex coordinates give and . For an anti-Hermitian matrix , the fundamental field is . Direct contraction yields
Consequently the unitary moment map of an isotropic oscillator in our declared convention is
It is real because is anti-Hermitian. Identifying with Hermitian matrices by , this is simply . Unitary invariance of proves conservation of all nine real matrix components. Under , the matrix transforms as , exactly the coadjoint transformation in this pairing. The origin is the required fixed point.
The bracket can also be checked without an equivariance theorem. For and , use
Differentiation gives . The central generator has , while a real antisymmetric generator has
Thus the special orthogonal group subgroup has the usual angular momentum components , with . The remaining unitary generators supply the other conserved quadratic observables, with their signs fixed by the stated choice of complex coordinates and Hamiltonian convention.
Fix the sign convention , where is the fundamental vector field and . A Hamiltonian group action is a symplectic Lie group action together with an equivariant moment map satisfying this identity for every . Equivariance means . Merely requiring each fundamental field to have some Hamiltonian is the weaker condition of a weakly Hamiltonian action.
For a circle group action, identify its Lie algebra with , and let generate the action. Put and let . Since is a regular value,
The action is free, so . The symplectic orthogonal complement of this hyperplane is exactly , which is contained in . Thus
The free action of the compact circle group is proper, and the quotient is a smooth manifold with projection a principal bundle. The form is invariant and kills the orbit directions, hence is basic and descends to a unique two-form satisfying . It is closed because pullback by a submersion detects differential forms. If a quotient tangent vector annihilates , a lift lies in the displayed kernel and hence projects to zero. Therefore is nondegenerate. This proves symplectic reduction directly.
If is a Lagrangian submanifold, its inverse image is a smooth circle bundle over . The restricted symplectic form is . If , then , , and , proving that is Lagrangian. This is the Lagrangian lift through circle reduction.
For scalar multiplication on , the generator is . Direct contraction gives
Choose . Its level is the sphere of radius and its quotient is . Complex conjugation on the sphere reverses the ambient symplectic form and descends to an anti-symplectic involution of the quotient. Its fixed set is : a projective point fixed by conjugation has a real representative after a phase change. For two tangent vectors to this fixed set, anti-symplecticity makes the reduced form equal to its negative, so it vanishes. The real dimension is , half the quotient dimension, proving the Lagrangian fixed locus of an anti-symplectic involution property.
The lifted Lagrangian submanifold can be written explicitly as
The only redundancy in this parametrization is the displayed free involution: two nonzero real representatives on the same complex ray differ by a real sign. The quotient embeds smoothly in the sphere, and projection to exhibits its circle bundle structure. Its Lagrangian property follows from the reduction argument, including the case .
Write for the fundamental vector field of a left Lie group action, and use throughout. Such fundamental fields satisfy . A moment map has linear components satisfying
For the action to be Hamiltonian, these components can be chosen equivariantly, or, infinitesimally,
This identifies the span of the component Hamiltonians with the Lie algebra image, rather than identifying the entire infinite-dimensional Poisson algebra with . For an actual isomorphism with , injectivity is also needed; a faithful infinitesimal action supplies it.
Preservation of alone gives , not necessarily exactness. For example, translation generated by on the symplectic two-torus has contraction , whose period is nonzero. That action has no globally defined component Hamiltonian. Once the contractions are exact, choose Hamiltonians linearly in . On each connected component of , the discrepancy
is constant: apply and the fundamental-field bracket. The Jacobi identity makes a Lie algebra two-cocycle. Replacing by changes it to . Thus the exactness condition and vanishing of this moment-map equivariance obstruction are precisely the required infinitesimal conditions.
For a semisimple Lie algebra, both hold. First Cartan's magic formula gives
Semisimplicity implies , so every generator is a sum of commutators and has a globally exact contraction. This proves Hamiltonian existence for a semisimple symplectic action.
Next use the nondegenerate Killing form to define by . Antisymmetry makes skew for . The cocycle identity and invariance of imply , so is a derivation. Choose by
Then, using cyclicity of trace and ,
Hence and . Taking removes the cocycle and proves semisimple moment-map equivariance without merely invoking a cohomology theorem. For a connected group, integrate the infinitesimal equivariance along its one-parameter subgroups to obtain group equivariance. A disconnected group can require an additional discrete-equivariance check.
Let be the moment map for the circle group, assume is a regular value, and assume the circle action on is free. The action is proper because the circle is compact. Then has dimension and is a smooth manifold of dimension .
If generates the action, for every . In fact is exactly the line spanned by , since is a hyperplane and is nondegenerate. Therefore the kernel of the restricted two-form is precisely the orbit direction. The restriction is invariant and horizontal, so it descends to a unique nondegenerate closed two-form with
This proves the Marsden-Weinstein theorem in the circle case. If the Hamiltonian is invariant, then : its Hamiltonian flow stays on , projects to the quotient and is generated there by the descended function . This is a reduced Hamiltonian system in local variables. At a critical level or a nonfree orbit the quotient can be singular, so the smooth dimension assertion needs the stated hypotheses.
For a mass- particle in the plane with central force potential , work on and write
Exterior differentiation gives . Rotation translates and has moment map . Fix and quotient out to obtain the planar rotational symplectic reduction
The reduced equations are and . The centrifugal term arises from the conserved angular momentum; it is not an extra force imposed by hand. Reconstruct the angle from . For the origin cannot lie on the level; for the same local reduction holds away from the origin, while the full phase-space origin is a singular fixed orbit.
Use and . For an actual infinitesimal left Lie group action, define . Its fundamental vector fields obey with this convention.
Existence and its global obstruction. Preservation of the symplectic form gives . By Cartan's magic formula, is closed. Locally it equals ; globally this requires its class in to vanish. If it does for every , choose potentials linearly in and define
This gives the component Hamiltonians of a weakly Hamiltonian action. The assumption in the question does not alone guarantee a global moment map: on with , translation in preserves , but its contraction is , whose integral around the circle is nonzero. It is not an exact one-form. Thus no global real-valued component Hamiltonian exists for that circle action. The intended construction is valid locally, or globally with this exactness condition, for example if .
Matching the Lie algebra. On each connected component, the moment-map equivariance obstruction is the constant
Indeed, the identities and show that its differential vanishes. The Jacobi identity for the Poisson bracket says
Changing by a linear constant changes to . Consequently the necessary and sufficient infinitesimal condition is the cocycle must be a coboundary, so that the constants can be chosen with
Equivalently its class in vanishes. For a connected group this infinitesimal equivariance integrates to equivariance under its coadjoint action. A disconnected group can impose additional conditions. Here “coincides” means representing the specified Lie brackets; it does not guarantee injectivity when the group action has ineffective generators.
Proof using the Killing form. A nondegenerate Killing form makes semisimple. First, it is perfect: the -orthogonal complement of is the center by invariance, and the center is zero by nondegeneracy. For symplectic fields,
by Cartan's magic formula and the antihomomorphism sign. Every commutator therefore has an exact contraction. Perfectness supplies component Hamiltonians for every generator, even when is not simply connected: this is Hamiltonian existence for a semisimple symplectic action.
It remains to eliminate the cocycle, not merely to name an existence theorem. Define a linear operator on by . Antisymmetry of makes skew for . Combining its cocycle identity with invariance of gives
Choose by , possible because is nondegenerate. Since is a derivation, . Cyclicity of the matrix trace then gives
Thus , and . Taking removes , proving the required condition. This applies to semisimple Lie groups, including for , and for . It is nondegeneracy, not positive definiteness, that matters. Groups with a nonzero central Lie algebra, such as , do not satisfy this Killing-form criterion, although particular actions can still have equivariant moment maps.
The isotropic oscillator. On , put
The action , , preserves the Hermitian norm and the symplectic form, and therefore preserves . A Hermitian matrix parametrizes the Lie algebra generator . Its unitary moment map of an isotropic oscillator is
Since , direct differentiation yields
The matrix is Hermitian and corresponds precisely to ; no central defect remains. The full moment map can be identified, using the pairing with Hermitian matrices, with the rank-one matrix . The central generator gives , whose flow is . Globally , so the “ factor” refers to this central circle, rather than a literal direct-product decomposition.
The real orthogonal subgroup acts geometrically by , the cotangent lift of a diffeomorphism of . If is real antisymmetric and , then . For , this is , so its three components are the usual angular momentum .
The remaining six independent Hermitian directions can be taken as real symmetric matrices. Their moment functions span
The diagonal ones are the individual oscillator energies; their sum is . The off-diagonal ones correlate two oscillator modes. Their flows mix positions and momenta and are not cotangent lifts of the obvious spatial rotation action: for a real symmetric , and , rather than , . All nine quadratic functions commute with , since the entire unitary group action preserves the oscillator Hamiltonian.
A Yang-Mills instanton is a localized finite-action Euclidean gauge field with self-dual or anti-self-dual gauge curvature. It is a four-dimensional space-time event, rather than a static three-dimensional finite-energy monopole. Take gauge group first, with Skew-Hermitian generators , , and . Write
and fix orientation . The positive Euclidean action is
Varying gives . Integration by parts makes stationarity equivalent to . The Bianchi identity follows by expanding , using , and cancelling the remaining matrix commutator terms. Consequently implies the Yang-Mills equations: . Self-duality of gauge curvature is an extra first-order condition, not a property of every finite-action gauge connection.
For the usual instanton decay conditions, the field is asymptotically pure gauge, on the sphere at infinity. The boundary map has an integer degree. With the present trace convention define the instanton number by
The identity
turns this integral into a boundary winding integral: for , the three-form in parentheses is , giving , with the chosen boundary orientation. The normalized invariant three-form computes the degree of , so . Equivalently the gauge bundle extends across conformal infinity to a bundle on , and this is its Second Chern number convention. A smooth deformation preserving the boundary class cannot change this integer.
Square completion gives the Yang-Mills instanton Bogomolny bound:
Self-dual gauge curvature saturates the bound for , and anti-self-dual gauge curvature for . These are Yang-Mills action minima within their topological sectors. Gauge variations give redundant directions, and variations along the moduli give zero modes; there is no negative second variation within the fixed-charge sector at a bound-saturating solution.
An explicit charge-one solution is the BPST instanton. Put , , , with . The self-dual 't Hooft symbols are defined by and , extended antisymmetrically. Then
For completeness, differentiation supplies , where . The matrix commutator term supplies , and the symbol identity
reduces their sum to the stated gauge curvature. Since , it is self-dual and solves the Yang-Mills equations. The gauge potential is regular at the center in this gauge, and gauge curvature falls as at infinity.
The squared-symbol sum is 12, so
The second integral follows from and the substitution . Thus
Replacing the symbols by their anti-self-dual counterparts reverses the charge and gives an anti-instanton. A compact non-Abelian group with an subgroup admits corresponding embedded examples.
The center gives four position moduli and gives one size modulus. In a framed instanton moduli space, gauge transformations are required to approach the identity at infinity, so three global orientation parameters remain, making eight real parameters for one instanton. If constant gauge transformations are also divided out, only the five position-and-size parameters remain. The size costs no classical Yang-Mills action: under , gauge curvature scales by and the four-dimensional volume by . As , gauge curvature concentrates at the center; the limiting object is a singular bubbling boundary of moduli space, not a smooth zero-size solution.
Higher-charge solutions require genuine nonlinear constructions, rather than a linear sum of charge-one gauge potentials. The ADHM construction gives a finite-dimensional description. For , , take , , , satisfying
modulo the natural group action of . Here is the charge magnitude, avoiding confusion with the signed above. Regularity requires the following matrix to have full row rank everywhere:
The complex constraint kills the off-diagonal block of , while the real constraint equates its diagonal blocks. Thus . Choose an orthonormal matrix of kernel columns , with , and define .
This is not merely a parameter count: its gauge curvature is checked by the ADHM factorization identity. The complementary orthogonal projection is . Differentiating in the identity gives
The space-time differential two-forms appearing here are generated by , , and . For orientation these are anti-self-dual. Hence the construction yields anti-self-dual gauge connections, of charge in the present convention; the reversed construction gives positive charge. Regular ADHM data describe the smooth framed instanton moduli, while degenerate rank conditions allow singular limits.
There are real data parameters. The three real matrix moment map equations impose conditions, and quotient by removes another , giving dimensions at regular points. For this is framed dimensions and unframed dimensions on the irreducible locus. This explains how the one-instanton parameters fit into the higher-charge family.
The Penrose-Ward correspondence provides a complementary description by holomorphic vector bundles on twistor space, trivial on the real twistor lines for the Euclidean problem and equipped with the suitable reality structure. Triviality on every complexified line is a stronger condition and is not required for ordinary Euclidean instantons. Symmetry reductions of the anti-self-dual equations give integrable three-dimensional systems such as the Bogomolny equations.
In the quantum theory, a Euclidean instanton interpolates between Yang-Mills vacua of different Chern-Simons number. Choosing Euclidean time and spatial orientation , its signed charge is the final Chern-Simons number minus the initial one, so it describes quantum tunnelling between winding sectors. Semiclassical contributions are suppressed by ; a Yang-Mills theta term adds a phase . One integrates over the instanton collective coordinates and includes fluctuation determinants rather than treating one classical solution as the entire quantum answer. Instantons therefore connect finite-action classical geometry, topology of gauge bundles, exact nonlinear constructions, and nonperturbative quantum effects.
Use , and
Then and . For a left group action, let ; its fundamental fields obey .
The components of a moment map satisfy
Thus . A Hamiltonian moment map additionally has coadjoint equivariance,
Here the right side evaluates on as . With that convention its infinitesimal form is . Some definitions reserve “moment map” for this equivariant version; choosing Hamiltonians for every generator first gives a weakly Hamiltonian action.
To derive the obstruction, compare the two antihomomorphism identities:
On connected , nondegeneracy of makes
a constant alternating bilinear form. The two Jacobi identities imply
Replacing by changes to . Thus vanishing of this class in Lie algebra cohomology is the precise moment-map equivariance obstruction. In particular a connected group with permits constants to be chosen so that the component Poisson algebra is the Lie algebra. A locally effective action makes this realization faithful; otherwise it realizes the quotient by the infinitesimal kernel. The linear span of the components has the Lie brackets; the entire algebra of polynomial products of them is, of course, larger.
A useful sufficient condition is semisimplicity, which can be proved here without assuming the desired equivariance. Let be the nondegenerate Killing form and define by . Invariance of and the cocycle identity give
so is a derivation. Choose uniquely by . Since , cyclicity of trace gives
Hence and . The shift removes the obstruction. This proves semisimple moment-map equivariance; for connected infinitesimal equivariance integrates along its one-parameter subgroups to group equivariance. It does not claim that arbitrary symplectic actions of arbitrary groups have moment maps.
For the Kepler calculation, put and work on , since the Hamiltonian is singular at the origin. The Hamilton equations are
The angular momentum therefore obeys
For the Runge-Lenz vector,
The vector triple product identity gives . Therefore
and the terms cancel. Since , this proves
The conserved quantities consequently generate transformations preserving energy. Their brackets give the Kepler dynamical symmetry algebra. On , define as a function on that whole open region. Because Poisson commutes with both vectors, its brackets are
With one obtains two commuting algebras:
Thus the negative-energy algebra is . On , using instead changes the last bracket to , yielding , with rotations and boosts. At zero energy the brackets of conserved functions on the characteristic orbit quotient give , with commuting .
There are two global qualifications. First, an energy hypersurface carries a presymplectic form: its restricted two-form has characteristic direction . At , the literal vector fields of need only commute modulo , since differentiating still produces an term. On nonzero-energy regions the energy-dependent normalization above gives an exact Hamiltonian Lie algebra; one must differentiate that normalization before restricting to a level. Second, completeness is required for a global group action. The collision-excluded Kepler phase space need not have complete hidden-symmetry flows, so the brackets establish local actions (or the appropriate simply connected covers), not an unconditional global action on every unregularized trajectory. Collision regularization supplies the familiar global bound-motion symmetry; this distinction is developed in math.berkeley.edu/~alanw/277papers00/tang.pdf . It does not change the three energy-dependent Lie algebras just derived.
The Marsden-Weinstein theorem needs a Hamiltonian action, not merely an action by symplectomorphisms. Assume an equivariant moment map exists, choose a coadjoint-fixed regular value (zero is the usual choice), and assume the action on is free and proper. Regularity makes a submanifold of codimension . Equivariance and invariance of make invariant under , and freeness and properness give a smooth quotient . Thus
Let and . For and ,
Moreover the conormal of is spanned by the independent , so nondegeneracy of gives . The coadjoint-fixed value makes these orbit directions tangent to . Hence the kernel of is exactly the orbit tangent space. The restricted form is invariant and horizontal, so descends uniquely to a two-form with
It is closed because is closed. If a quotient tangent vector annihilates , any lift lies in the kernel just identified and is vertical; the quotient vector is therefore zero. This proves nondegeneracy and completes symplectic reduction.
If the action is not free, singular strata or orbifold phenomena may occur. At a general noncentral regular value one quotients by its coadjoint stabilizer , not by all of ; the regular dimension is . These are genuine hypotheses behind the stated dimension formula.
Both proposed examples can be given explicitly. For symplectic reduction of an isotropic oscillator, take two modes with
Its Hamiltonian flow is , a circle action with moment map . For , is the sphere of radius , and the action is free. The Hopf fibration identifies its quotient with . On the chart , use and choose a section with real positive. Pulling back to this section gives
Writing gives , whose integral is . This is the Fubini-Study form scaled by in the convention of area at unit scale. The reduced dimension is . At , the circle fixes the origin and the smooth regular-level hypotheses fail.
For a unit-mass free particle in the plane, use the rotation circle action with angular-momentum moment map . Choose so the entire level avoids and the action is free. Polar canonical coordinates have
Fixing and quotienting the rotation angle leaves
This planar rotational symplectic reduction replaces a planar free trajectory by radial motion with the centrifugal potential. A nonzero moment value is allowed because the circle is abelian and every value is coadjoint-fixed.
Use the scalar components of the three chiral superfields, and set , , and . We assume the physical sign and a nonzero coupling . The coefficient below is exactly the coefficient in the supplied D-term scalar potential; it should not be silently replaced by a differently normalized squared gauge coupling. The canonical Kähler potential has identity Kähler metric, and the three Kähler covariant derivatives of a superpotential are
Substitution in the supergravity F-term potential gives
In particular, the subtraction cancels only half of the six terms contributed by the three squares. The full scalar potential is
Its nonnegativity follows term by term from and . This is a special property of this cubic superpotential, not of a general supergravity F-term potential.
The D-term vacuum branches of a cubic superpotential must be described as branches: there are not two isolated field-space minima. First suppose . Vanishing of requires , and vanishing of the D-term scalar potential requires . Together these conditions give the vacuum expectation values
The phase of lies on a gauge orbit, and one may choose it positive and real. At this global minimum, all and the real auxiliary field of the vector multiplet vanish. It is a supersymmetric vacuum, even though the internal gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken. For , interchange and : the nonzero vacuum expectation value has magnitude . For , the supersymmetric vacuum is the entire family , with arbitrary.
The other branch has and arbitrary . Here but the real auxiliary field is nonzero for , and
Thus this branch has pure D-term supersymmetry breaking and a flat direction of a scalar potential in the neutral scalar. It is not stable at every neutral-field value. At a fixed , expansion in the charged scalars yields
Hence the two charged squared masses and the stability condition are
Above this threshold, both charged directions have positive mass squared. Continuity makes them uniformly positive in a sufficiently small neighborhood of the chosen neutral-field value, so the stationary branch is a genuine, non-strict local minimum valley. Its neutral direction stays flat. Below the threshold, a charged mass squared is negative and the branch is a saddle point. At equality it is a boundary of the stable valley, not a local minimum in the full field space: changing slightly downward and switching on the unstable charged field lowers . For example, for , put , , . Since has , one finds .
There are no further local-minimum branches under these generic assumptions. If , the expression for is strictly increasing in , so a stationary configuration with a charged condensate must have . At , an interior critical point with is impossible, because
On the boundary , the relevant scalar potential is ; on it is . Their nonnegative-domain minima give exactly the supersymmetric vacuum described above, or the origin of the charged-field branch. Thus, for nonzero , the two types are the zero-energy supersymmetric gauge orbit and the positive-energy D-breaking minimum valley above the threshold. If , the two types coalesce into the flat supersymmetric vacuum; the literal two-minimum assertion needs this parameter qualification.
In the global supersymmetry limit , the F-term scalar potential becomes and the D-term scalar potential retains its form. The same two types of branches occur, with the threshold . Supergravity instead introduces the exponential and additional positive terms. The goldstino of global supersymmetry breaking is a physical fermion; in local supersymmetry it participates in the super-Higgs mechanism. A positive vacuum energy also gravitates in supergravity. In particular, the positive-energy branch here has and hence vanishing gravitino mass from a superpotential; it is not the tuned zero-energy broken vacuum of Question 3.
There is a further gauge-consistency qualification. In conventional two-derivative matter-coupled supergravity, a constant Fayet–Iliopoulos term gauges an R-symmetry and requires a corresponding nontrivial transformation of the superpotential. The apparent charges make the supplied cubic superpotential neutral, so a nonzero independent constant does not by itself specify a consistent conventional supergravity action. The computed branches are those of the supplied scalar potential; a full embedding needs compatible charges or additional fields. This restriction is explained in Van Proeyen's derivation of the superpotential gauge-covariance condition.
More generally, the supergravity moment-map constraint on D-term breaking follows directly from gauge covariance. If and the moment map is , then at a point with ,
Consequently all chiral auxiliary fields vanishing implies the D-term also vanishes there. This relation has no analogue forcing that implication in an arbitrary global supersymmetry model. Its hypothesis matters: the formal D-breaking branch above has , so it does not contradict the identity. These conventional gauge-completion restrictions are additional to the elementary minimization calculation.
In Lagrangian mechanics, let a one-parameter group on have generator . Its tangent lift acts on as
If is invariant, . Along an Euler–Lagrange trajectory, the Noether conserved quantity for a mechanical point symmetry is
because
Thus the conserved quantity is explicitly derived, not merely attached to the name of a symmetry. If the change of is the total derivative , then is conserved. For a general point transformation with time component , the conserved expression is , provided the variation of is . Time-translation invariance of an autonomous Lagrangian therefore yields conservation of energy.
In Hamiltonian mechanics, a cotangent-lifted action preserves and hence . For its infinitesimal generator , Cartan's magic formula gives
where . These components define the canonical moment map , with . If is invariant, , so . This is the Hamiltonian form of Noether's theorem, and the Legendre transform in mechanics identifies its charges with the Lagrangian ones.
More generally, a Hamiltonian group action is an action whose infinitesimal symplectic generators have globally defined Hamiltonian functions. The existence of those functions is an assumption, not a consequence of every symplectic action. For example, translation on a symplectic two-torus preserves but contraction with gives , which is closed and not globally exact. Such a symmetry need not have a globally single-valued moment-map component. On , the cotangent lift does have the canonical components just derived. A Hamiltonian symmetry preserving gives a conserved generator; the global momentum-map hypotheses must be stated.
A Hamiltonian group action is a smooth Lie group action of on by symplectomorphisms, together with an equivariant moment map . For , let be its fundamental vector field. In our sign convention the defining identities are
Here the left coadjoint action means . Each component is therefore a Hamiltonian function for the corresponding infinitesimal action. Equivariance is part of the definition; merely requiring each infinitesimal generator to be a Hamiltonian vector field is the weaker condition of a weakly Hamiltonian action. Reversing the defining sign of Hamiltonian vector fields reverses the moment map sign as well.
The Marsden-Weinstein theorem says that for a Hamiltonian group action, if is a regular value fixed by the coadjoint action and acts freely and properly on , then
is a symplectic manifold with a unique form characterized by , where includes the level set and is the quotient projection. Its dimension is .
Equip with the standard symplectic form
Let the circle group act by . Its generator is , and
Consequently the moment map in our convention is . It is invariant, hence equivariant because the circle group is abelian. The level is the sphere of radius ; it is regular, the circle group acts freely there, and properness follows from compactness of the group. The quotient is Complex projective space, by , a scaled Hopf fibration. The Marsden-Weinstein theorem therefore produces a reduced symplectic form on .
To identify it rather than only assert its existence, use the primitive
On the affine chart choose the local section of the quotient. Direct substitution gives
Differentiating, using , gives
This is the Fubini-Study form from circle reduction. The unit sphere instead produces half this form; our radius is exactly what gives the line-area normalization used above.
For , the fundamental vector field of the restricted Lie group action is . If is the original moment map, then
This is the defining Hamiltonian action identity, in the convention .
If equivariance is included in the definition of a moment map, it is also preserved: the dual map intertwines the coadjoint actions of , since . Thus
is a moment map for the restricted Hamiltonian action of the Lie subgroup .