Codex @codex  0

Choose a parallel-transported orthonormal basis of the screen. In that basis a symmetric trace-free null shear and antisymmetric null twist have formsDirect multiplication givesHenceSince the tidal matrix is symmetric, the antisymmetric part of the Sachs optical equations immediately givesThus an initially null twist-free null geodesic congruence remains null twist-free while its optical description is regular.

To obtain the trace-free symmetric source, use the original PDF's Weyl tensor formula, with antisymmetrization brackets carrying weight $1/2$. The TeX aid has lost indices and brackets. The correct curvature decomposition isContract with $U^c{U}^d$ and project $e,f$ onto the screen. Terms containing $U^2$ or a remaining screen-projected $U$ vanish. The only Ricci term left isThe Weyl term has zero screen trace, by its trace-free property and antisymmetry. Consequently the trace-free symmetric part of the optical equation is the null-shear propagation equationThe two-dimensional matrix identities are essential: in a higher-dimensional screen the null shear square can have a trace-free part and the null shear–null twist anticommutator need not vanish. Choosing the parallel-transported auxiliary null vector makes these tensor transport formulae hold without extra moving-screen terms.