There is no single reliably poisonous dose for each opium preparation. Identify the preparation and exposure, but diagnose and treat poisoning from its effects, especially depressed breathing. Toxicity depends on the actual alkaloid content, route, age, opioid tolerance, coexisting illness and other depressants. A quantity tolerated by one person may produce dangerous respiratory depression in another. In particular, neither a historical ordinary dose nor a published fatal quantity defines a boundary below which every person is safe.[ref]
Opioid overdose by WHO. Risk factors and the characteristic combination of impaired consciousness, depressed breathing and pinpoint pupils
For the historical numerical part, separate formulation strength from a poisonous threshold. The relevant British formulations are those associated with the British Pharmacopoeia by the General Medical Council (1864), not a later edition or the bracketed American recipes in The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). In the following comparisons, a grain is a mass unit and a minim a volume unit; a fluid ounce is 480 minims. These comparisons describe period preparations and are not administration instructions.
- Opium tincture and the 1864 Vinum Opii are each described as containing the soluble constituents of one grain of dry opium in approximately 14½ minims. Tinctura Camphorae cum Opio contains one grain in half a fluid ounce, or 240 minims. Confusing these liquids therefore creates a large error in exposure.
- Extractum Opii is an aqueous extract with potency dependent on extraction and starting material. The contemporary comparison gives about half a grain of dry extract as equivalent to one grain of raw opium. Extractum Opii Liquidum contains about one grain of extract in 22 minims. This is an approximate raw-drug equivalence, not an assay of morphine.
- Pilula Opii contains one part opium in five parts pill mass; Pilula Plumbi cum Opio one in eight. The latter also carries the independent hazard of a lead compound.
- Pulvis Ipecacuanhae cum Opio, Pulvis Kino cum Opio and Pulvis Cretae Aromaticus cum Opio contain one part opium in ten, twenty and forty parts respectively. Other ingredients do not abolish opioid toxicity.
These strengths make clear how to compare exposures once their quantities are known. For example, if a preparation contains a mass fraction of dry opium and a mass of it was taken, its nominal raw-drug content isThat equation cannot supply an unknown toxic threshold or account for all differences in absorption.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Posological Table, final Opium comparison: British strengths and approximate extract equivalence
Two entries require explicit textual caution. The monograph for Trochisci Opii specifies 72 grains of Extractum Opii divided into 720 lozenges, hence one tenth of a grain of extract per lozenge; its summary table instead says one tenth of a grain of opium. Those are not interchangeable descriptions. Similarly, the Enema Opii recipe specifies 30 minims of opium tincture with two fluid ounces of starch decoction, whereas the summary table describes one grain of opium in two fluid ounces. At the stated tincture strength the recipe contributes about two grains to the mixture, so the discrepancy should not be silently turned into a precise rectal poisonous dose.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Papaverceae, Parts 2–3: Enema Opii recipe and Trochisci Opii recipe; compare Posological Table
The external preparations also belong to the officinal list: Emplastrum Opii, Linimentum Opii and Unguentum Gallae cum Opio. The plaster contains one part powdered opium to nine parts resin plaster; the liniment mixes equal volumes of opium tincture and soap liniment. The galls ointment is described as approximately one part opium in 14½ parts of ointment. These are not oral medicines. Exposure over damaged skin, contact with mucosa or accidental swallowing cannot be evaluated by assigning a universal number of spoonfuls or applications.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Papaverceae, Part 2: plaster and liniment; Part 3: galls and opium ointment
If preparations derived from the purified alkaloid are included, distinguish them from raw opium: Liquor Morphiae Hydrochloratis contains four grains of morphine hydrochloride per fluid ounce; Suppositoria Morphiae contain a quarter grain each; Trochisci Morphiae and Trochisci Morphiae et Ipecacuanhae contain one thirty-sixth of a grain of the salt per lozenge. A raw-drug fraction is not the same thing as a mass of purified morphine hydrochloride.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Papaverceae, Part 3, Of Hydrochlorate of Morphia: solution, suppositories and the two lozenges
Deep historical narcotism means profound opioid poisoning, with depressed consciousness and dangerously slow or ineffective breathing, often with small pupils. Current priorities are emergency help, an open airway, assisted ventilation and oxygen therapy as required, and prompt naloxone. If there is cardiac arrest, start appropriate cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Repeat naloxone or use an infusion when clinically required, and continue observation because the opioid may outlast the reversal. A transient awakening is not proof of sustained recovery.[ref][ref]
Responding to a Suspected Opioid Overdose by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. Emergency response, naloxone and continuing assistance
Older attempts to empty the stomach or to rouse an unconscious person must not displace respiratory support. Do not give oral drinks or an emetic to an unconscious person, and do not perform unprotected gastric instrumentation: aspiration can add a second cause of respiratory failure. The concise therapeutic answer is therefore support ventilation and reverse the opioid effect, rather than waiting for a calculated poisonous dose to be exceeded.
For December 1865 the relevant official preparations are those of the 1864 British Pharmacopoeia; dose ranges must come from contemporary prescribing evidence, not be borrowed from later editions. The first edition specified identities and preparations without supplying a universal clinical dose for every article. The following are historical adult quantities from The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865), using its British entries rather than bracketed United States formulas. They are not current prescribing instructions or established safe limits. “Grain” is a unit of mass; “minim”, fluid drachm and fluid ounce are units of volume. One Imperial fluid drachm contains 60 minims, and one fluid ounce contains eight fluid drachms. A minim is not an arbitrary drop.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). introduction, British weights and measures; posological table
For arsenic, distinguish the elemental substance from its medicinal compounds. The relevant series comprises Acidum Arseniosum, Liquor Arsenicalis, Sodae Arsenias, Liquor Sodae Arseniatis and Ferri Arsenias. The contemporary ranges are arsenic trioxide about 1/60–1/12 grain; arsenical solution 2–5 minims, occasionally 10; crystalline sodium arsenate 1/12–1/2 grain, or its dried salt 1/20–1/4 grain; its official solution 5–30 minims; ferrous arsenate 1/10–1/8 grain. Hydrated and dried salts cannot be exchanged grain for grain. The two official arsenical solutions each contain four grains of their specified ingredient per fluid ounce, but the ingredients are different. The solution of arsenic and mercury discussed alongside them was non-official, and Liquor Arsenici Hydrochloricus was an addition in 1867: neither belongs in an unqualified list of 1864 preparations.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). arsenious acid, sodium arsenate, ferrous arsenate; posological table
[ref]For copper, the medicinal article is purified Cupri Sulphas, copper sulfate: 1/4–2 grains as a historical astringent or tonic, 5–8 grains as a historical emetic. An external solution was described as 1–10 grains or more per fluid ounce, depending on the intended local action. The anhydrous test reagent and copper compounds listed among analytical materials are not additional ordinary internal preparations. Neither the historical emetic use nor an external concentration authorises modern oral use.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). purified copper sulfate, medicinal doses and distinction from analytical copper salts
For opium, the contemporary monograph gives powdered opium and Extractum Opii, 1/4–3 grains or more; Extractum Opii Liquidum, Tinctura Opii and Vinum Opii, 4–40 minims or more; Tinctura Camphorae cum Opio, 1–2 fluid drachms. These are the author's reported ranges, not maxima. His summary table differs, listing 3–30 minims for liquid extract and 1/2–4 grains for powdered opium; that internal variation should remain visible rather than being converted into an invented single official limit.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Action of the other constituents of opium, Dose; compare Posological table
The compound oral opium preparations require their own quantities: Pilula Opii, 2 1/2 grains upwards; Pilula Plumbi cum Opio, 4–8 grains; Pulvis Cretae Aromaticus cum Opio, 10–60 grains; Pulvis Ipecacuanhae cum Opio, a reference quantity of 5 grains upwards; Pulvis Kino cum Opio, 10 grains upwards; Trochisci Opii, one to four lozenges. In the same order, the pill masses and powders contain approximately one part opium in 5, 8, 40, 10 and 20; each opium lozenge contains 1/10 grain. “Upwards” in the historical source does not establish a safe upper boundary: the required opium content, other ingredients and circumstances controlled the quantity. The lead-containing pill has an additional toxic constituent. Enema Opii supplies about one grain of opium in the official two-fluid-ounce enema; this is a rectal preparation, not an oral measure.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). opium preparations; posological table and table of ingredient proportions
The external opium preparations, Emplastrum Opii, Linimentum Opii and Unguentum Gallae cum Opio, have no ordinary swallowed dose. For completeness the official isolated alkaloid series was Morphiae Hydrochloras, Liquor Morphiae Hydrochloratis, Suppositoria Morphiae, Trochisci Morphiae and Trochisci Morphiae et Ipecacuanhae. The reported historical quantities are morphine hydrochloride, 1/8–1 grain; its solution, 20 minims to two fluid drachms in the monograph; one suppository containing 1/4 grain; either kind of morphine lozenge, one to four, each containing 1/36 grain. The summary table gives a narrower upper quantity of one fluid drachm for the solution. These large historical ranges must not be interpreted as safe for a person without opioid tolerance. The solution contains four grains per fluid ounce. Neither a morphine-acetate preparation added later nor a non-official compound confection should be substituted for this 1864 series.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). opium, morphine preparations, doses and ingredient proportions
For belladonna, Extractum Belladonnae, 1/6–1 grain; Tinctura Belladonnae, 5–30 minims. Emplastrum Belladonnae, Linimentum Belladonnae and Unguentum Belladonnae are external preparations, not additional oral doses. The associated Atropia, Liquor Atropiae and Unguentum Atropiae likewise require their route to be stated: this author specifically discourages routine internal atropine administration and describes ophthalmic use of the solution. Its strength is four grains per fluid ounce; the ointment contains eight grains per ounce. These are historical formulation strengths, not a modern eye-drop or oral prescription. The atropine-sulfate series introduced in 1867 is not the 1864 series.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Solanaceae and continuation; Belladonna and Atropia in the ingredient table
For Strychnia, strychnine, the historical range was 1/32–1/8 grain; Liquor Strychniae, 5–15 minims, the solution containing four grains per fluid ounce. If the botanical preparations yielding the alkaloid are included, powdered nux vomica, 1–3 grains; Extractum Nucis Vomicae, 1/4–2 grains; Tinctura Nucis Vomicae, 10–30 minims. The American editor already warned that the two-grain extract quantity was very large and that more than half a grain commonly risked adverse effects. Keeping that qualification is more faithful than presenting the printed upper range as routine or safe.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Loganiaceae, solution, doses and editorial footnote
For cinchona bark, powdered yellow, pale or red bark, 10–60 grains; Decoctum Cinchonae Flavae and Infusum Cinchonae Flavae, 1–2 fluid ounces; Extractum Cinchonae Flavae Liquidum, 10–60 minims; Tinctura Cinchonae Flavae and Tinctura Cinchonae Composita, 1–2 fluid drachms. The associated Tinctura Quiniae Composita was given at 1–2 fluid drachms. The isolated official quinine sulfate, Quiniae Sulphas, was listed at 1–10 grains, with larger quantities discussed for particular intermittent fevers. Ferri et Quiniae Citras, the official iron-and-quinine preparation, was listed at 5–20 grains. Other cinchona alkaloids discussed as possible remedies do not thereby become official preparations. Strength in bark equivalents also does not guarantee a fixed amount of extracted quinine.[ref]
The Essentials of Materia Medica and Therapeutics by Alfred Baring Garrod (1865). Cinchonaceae Part 4; Action of the different kinds of cinchona barks, Dose; posological table, citrate of iron and quinine
These figures answer a historical materia medica question. Current drug safety requires the exact modern product, route, indication and patient factors; poisonous nineteenth-century “tonics” and emetics are not revived by accurate transcription of their period doses. Strychnine can cause severe painful convulsions; opioids can depress breathing; and inorganic arsenic is a toxic and carcinogenic exposure. Those facts undermine any reading of the historical numbers as a self-treatment schedule.[ref]
Strychnine by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. clinical effects and emergency treatment
[ref]Opioid overdose by WHO. respiratory depression and overdose
[ref]Arsenic by WHO. acute effects, chronic exposure and carcinogenicity