Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2017 3 c Solution 2026-10-25
Suppose, for a contradiction, that . Then too. Both prime ideals are disjoint from the multiplicatively closed set . The localization iseach fraction on the left has rational coefficients, and every polynomial with rational coefficients has a common nonzero integer denominator.
By b, the extended prime ideals form a strict inclusionThe first is nonzero, because contains a nonzero polynomial and the map is injective.
The polynomial ring is a principal ideal domain: in any nonzero ideal, a nonzero polynomial of least polynomial degree generates the ideal, since the polynomial division algorithm gives a remainder of smaller polynomial degree, which must be zero. By a, every nonzero prime ideal of this principal ideal domain is maximal. The strict inclusion of extended prime ideals is therefore impossible. We obtain
Past exam of the commutative algebra course of the University of Oxford 2017 3 d Solution 2026-10-25
For any prime number , there is a prime chainin . These are prime ideals because the respective quotient rings are , , and , all integral domains. The inclusions are strict because and . Hence .
To prove the upper bound, suppose there were a prime chain of length at least three. Since is an integral domain, we could insert at its beginning if necessary and select a chainBy c, . This intersection is a proper prime ideal of : if a product of integers lies in it, primality of puts one factor in it. Therefore for a prime number , and .
We need to check that . Here prime ideals below a principal prime give the necessary restriction: no nonzero prime ideal can lie strictly below . If , then . Choose and factor out the largest common power of from its integer coefficients:Such a finite exists because has at least one nonzero integer coefficient. Since and is a prime ideal, repeated primality gives , a contradiction. Applied to , this rules out .
It follows that is a nonzero prime ideal ofAs in c, the polynomial division algorithm makes a principal ideal domain, so its nonzero prime ideals are maximal by a. Thus is maximal. The ideal correspondence theorem makes a maximal ideal of , contradicting . Consequently