Past exam of the mathematics course of the University of Cambridge / 2005 / iii / Paper 59 / 1

Apply the Schmidt decomposition to the bipartite pure state. Local unitary operators put it in the form $|{\psi }_{\theta }⟩=\cos \theta |00⟩+\sin \theta |11⟩$, with $0<\theta \le \pi /4$ after interchanging basis vectors. Both Schmidt coefficients are nonzero because the state is entangled. Put $s=\sin 2\theta >0$.

For this state, direct application of the Pauli operators givesFor example ${\sigma }_x\otimes {\sigma }_x$ interchanges $|00⟩$ and $|11⟩$, giving $2\cos \theta \sin \theta$; the crossed products take these two kets into their orthogonal complement.

Choose the CHSH axes for an entangled pure two-qubit state:Their associated Bloch vectors have unit length, so each is a valid two-outcome projective measurement with projectors $(I\pm A_i)/2$ or $(I\pm B_j)/2$. The correlation combination isA local hidden-variable assignment with outcomes $\pm 1$ gives absolute value at most two: exactly one of $b_0+b_1$ and $b_0-b_1$ vanishes, while the other is $\pm 2$. Averaging these assignments preserves that bound, which is the CHSH inequality.

Therefore $\boxed{\mathcal{S}=2\sqrt{1+{\sin }^{2}2\theta }>2}$. For the original state $(U\otimes V)|{\psi }_{\theta }⟩$, conjugate Alice's observables by $U$ and Bob's by $V$. These conjugations rotate their measurement axes and preserve all the displayed correlations. Thus every entangled pure two-qubit state has the requested violating axes. The maximally entangled case gives $2\sqrt{2}$, while the unentangled limit merely saturates two.